If you see this text then you need to update your flash player.

Print this pagePrint this page.

Recent Publications by New English Review Authors
In Praise of Prejudice: The Necessity of Preconceived Ideas
by Theodore Dalrymple
Defending The West:
by Ibn Warraq
Nations, Language and Citizenship:
by Norman Berdichevsky
Romancing Opiates
by Theodore Dalrymple
Which Koran?
by Ibn Warraq
Our Culture, What's Left of It
by Theodore Dalrymple
What The Koran Really Says
by Ibn Warraq
Life at the Bottom
by Theodore Dalrymple
The Origins of the Koran
by Ibn Warraq
Why I Am Not Muslim
by Ibn Warraq
Spanish Vignettes: An Offbeat Look Into Spain's Culture, Society & History
by Norman Berdichevsky
Leaving Islam
Edited by Ibn Warraq
These are all the Blogs posted on Friday, 18, 2008.
Friday, 18 July 2008
Government funds Muslim thinkers

From The BBC
The British government is to fund a board of Islamic theologians in an attempt to sideline violent extremists.
The move will see Oxford and Cambridge Universities host a group of scholars who will lead debate on key issues such as women and loyalty to the UK.
Under the plans, the two universities will bring together about 20 leading thinkers, yet to be named, to debate critical issues affecting Muslims in the UK. The Department for Communities is responsible for the government's strategy to combat violent extremism, known as "Prevent".
It will provide funding and support for the project but maintains that the board's work will be completely independent of political interference.  The board's work will focus on examining issues relating to Islam's place in Britain and obligations as a citizen.
Ministers say the board's membership will "reflect the diversity of Islam and Muslim communities in the UK" and the work will include seminars around the country.
Sheikh Ibrahim Mogra, a leading imam with the Muslim Council of Britain, said establishing a specialist board was the brainchild of a group of Muslims, not the government.
Ms Blears said the department's support for the project emerged out of debate with Muslim communities who asked ministers for help in supporting the work of key thinkers across the UK.  “We have made significant progress working with communities to build an alliance against violent extremists," said Ms Blears. "It is not for government to dictate on matters of faith or religious teaching. But Muslim communities themselves have told us that stronger leadership is needed on what are often controversial issues."
But Islamic groups who have clashed in the past with the government have already attacked the plans.
Taji Mustafa of Hizb ut-Tahrir, a group that fought government attempts to ban it, predicted that many ordinary Muslims would be suspicious. "The British government's interference amongst the Muslim community and matters of Islam, is unprecedented in comparison with any other religion," said Mr Mustafa.

Posted on 2:36 AM by Esmerelda Weatherwax
Friday, 18 July 2008
Mosque gets go-ahead after appeal

From The Express and Star the newspaper for the Midlands.
A mosque and training centre costing £18 million could still be built in Dudley after an appeal was upheld by a planning inspector sparking accusations the views of thousands of protesters have been ignored. But there is still a chance the scheme, featuring a 65 feet minaret, will fail if it has not been “substantially” built by the end of the year.
The decision to allow the appeal for the project on land in Hall Street was announced yesterday following a public inquiry held in June.
One of the key arguments against the plan was the fact the site had been designated for employment use. But the planning inspector said there were plenty of other pockets of land in Dudley which could be developed for industry.
Council leader David Caunt has described the decision as a “sad day” for local democracy saying it ignores the 23,000 people who signed a petition in opposition.
He said: “Once again the views of local people and councillors have been ignored by a planning inspectorate in Bristol. It is a sad day for local democracy when the council and the people are ridden roughshod over by a government quango. We will be reviewing the decision in detail to ascertain whether there are legal grounds to challenge it.”
Dudley Muslim Association which is behind the plan now has outline planning permission but still needs to submit a detailed application which the council has up to 13 weeks to determine.
When the site was transferred to the association in 2003 there was a legal agreement that if the project was not “substantially” completed by the end of this year the land would be returned to the council.
Council Caunt added: “I don’t think there will even be a bucket and spade on the site by then. There is every chance this will end up in the courts because the association will not back down.” Mr Caunt added he would be writing to Hazel Blears and branding her white paper “Communities in Control” a joke.
In contrast the PCBBC baldly states:-
The government has given permission for a new £18m mosque and community centre to be built in the West Midlands. . . The town's Muslim Association appealed to the government's Planning Inspectorate which has given the go-ahead for the project.
Graphic of proposed new mosque in DudleyLess than 7 months to get something which looks like the photo on the left substantially built, assuming the detailed application is granted. I doubt it is likely. The association will then return to court to argue against the 2003 agreement and the council will be put to more expense, all of which will be born by the Council tax payers. This is a war of paper and cunning which we can all fight no matter how old we are.

Posted on 2:59 AM by Esmerelda Weatherwax
Friday, 18 July 2008
Today in The Religion of Peace (tm)
On this day, July 18th, in 1857, the Islamic seige of the French colonial army at Medina Fort in present-day Mali was repulsed when reinforcements arrived from Senegal.  Islamic cleric El Hajj Umar Tall led the Muslim attack, after spending decades studying the Qur'an and years stockpiling weapons for the self-declared jihad against the Christian French.
 
In the aftermath of Umar Tall's failure against the Christian French, he redirected his jihad attacks against the animist Bambara kingdoms in Mali.  After they were successfully conquered, he attacked and invaded other Islamic kingdoms along the Middle Niger River.  He unfortunately did not die a martyr's death, as he was killed in an accidental detonation of his explosive stockpiles.
Posted on 7:24 AM by Artemis Gordon Glidden
Friday, 18 July 2008
A Musical Interlude: Mon Légionnaire (Marie Dubas)
Posted on 7:33 AM by Hugh Fitzgerald
Friday, 18 July 2008
Beatle Obama

There was no Beatle about the Bush, but Barack Obama is the "Fab One", according to Gerard Baker. From The Times:

You have to go back to the Beatles' first US tour to find a transatlantic trip freighted with the sort of pregnant excitement that attends the one Barack Obama is about to make next week.

The faces of the crowds expected in Berlin when he arrives on Thursday will be portraits of the same devotional ecstasy that greeted the Liverpool quartet on their way from JFK to Manhattan that February day in 1964. In London next weekend Gordon Brown will play Ed Sullivan to the Fab One, hoping to borrow, just for a day, a little of the superstar charisma to bolster his own ratings.

The parallels between the former Quarrymen and the son of the Kenyan goatherd don't stop there. Both built their success on a pleasing facility for the harmonious marriage of words and cadence. (“We have a righteous wind at our backs and we stand on the crossroads of history”, says the Senator. “Please please me, whoa yeah, like I please you!” sang John and Paul.)

Just like the Beatles, Mr Obama is a prodigiously talented revolutionary, the tribune of a rising generation, whose evident talent is only slightly compromised by an unsettling precocity. He hasn't claimed to be more popular than Jesus yet, but looking at the latest opinion polls in secular Europe, it might just be plausible.

Here are some more songs by Obama the Beatle:

The Taxman
All You Need is Love
Michelle, Ma Belle
Love Me Do
Ob A Me, Ob A Ma
Get Black

Posted on 7:54 AM by Mary Jackson
Friday, 18 July 2008
The Child-Murderer As Hero, Or, That's All We Need To Know
From the Montreal Gazette (Friday, July 18, 2008)
 
How do you welcome a child murderer as a hero?
Gil Troy

Depending on the tone, this question becomes an attempt to clarify, or an expression of outrage. Stated calmly, "How do you welcome a child murderer as a hero?" can be a factual question - such as the one that faced Lebanese leaders this week as they proceeded to celebrate the freeing of Samir Kuntar from an Israeli prison, where he had been held since 1979 for murdering 4-year-old Einat Haran, her father Danny Haran, and a policeman.

Stated angrily, "How do you welcome a child murderer as a hero?" is the question Israelis are asking - and the rest of the civilized world should be asking, too.

On the night of April 22, 1979, Kuntar, working with three other terrorists, took Danny and Einat hostage, marching them to the Mediterranean beach after seizing them in their home in the coastal city of Nahariya. After shooting Danny in front of his daughter, then drowning him to make sure he was dead, Kuntar turned on Einat. Swinging his rifle butt, he smashed the 4-year-old's head against the rocks, until she too died.

Adding to the horror, Einat's mother, Smadar, hiding in a crawl space, accidentally smothered 2-year-old Yael Haran while trying to stifle her whimpering.

Any civilized court of law would hold the attackers responsible for the toddler's death, too. Judging by the euphoria in Lebanon and in the Palestinian territories this week, by the terrorists' barbaric, topsy-turvy immoral logic, the additional carnage enhances Kuntar's heroic status.

Of course, this kind of language is terribly impolite. We Westerners are not supposed to call ourselves "civilized" and deem others "barbaric." For decades now we have been told that such terms are too judgmental, too culturally-determined, too imperialistic, too arrogant.

We have been so sensitized and issues have become so relativized many of us have lost our moral bearings. We have to call Kuntar a "militant," a "fighter" but not a "terrorist." We are supposed to explore Kuntar's motivations.

And besides, whatever his motives, we are expected to excuse his crimes by pointing to equally heinous Western sins, or the religious-cultural-nationalist foundations for his actions.

And yet, occasionally, illuminating moments of moral clarity shine through the haze of amoral theorizing that emanates from our finest campuses, that is disseminated by our most technologically sophisticated media. We all witnessed such a moment this week with Israel's heart-breaking prisoner exchange.

As the two coffins bearing the bodies of Eldad Regev and Ehud Goldwasser arrived in Israel from Lebanon, the nation of Israel plunged into mourning. These two young men became the entire country's collective children. Strangers who had never met either of them wept bitterly, sharing the pain of the family and the friends, remembering other losses, fearing more tragedies in the future.

By contrast, the massive celebrations in Lebanon for Kuntar and four other terrorists revealed not only the thuggery of Hezbollah but the descent of Lebanon itself. Rolling out the red carpet for a murderer, dispatching the country's top leaders to greet someone who crushed a 4-year-old's skull, declaring a national day of celebration, revealed just how thoroughly the Lebanese leadership had succumbed to the brutal sensibilities of Hassan Nasrallah and his Hezbollah terrorists.

At first glance, it is easy to conclude that the country that is mourning lost this week and the country celebrating won. In fact, Israel won a great moral victory. Israel showed why Westerners should and will support the Jewish state, empathize with the Jewish state, identify with the Jewish state.

We want to side with the country that moves heaven and Earth to bring its boys home, to protect its citizens; not with the country of bloodthirsty mobs deifying cowards who smashed the skull of a 4-year-old girl with a rifle butt on a lovely Mediterranean beach. We learn about a people by observing whom they love and whom they hate. Joy is fleeting and often triggered by base instincts. Sometimes collective anguish is a sign of moral strength, not national weakness.

"I'm proud to belong to those who love and not to those who hate," Ofer Regev said while eulogizing his brother Eldad. Israelis should be proud of this moment of moral clarity - and wary of enemies with such distorted value systems. Israel's - and the West's - enemies are wrong.

A nation that risks so much even just to bring two corpses home, a country that celebrates life not death, is not only a worthy ally - but a dangerous adversary when provoked."

Gil Troy teaches history at McGill University.

Posted on 9:21 AM by Hugh Fitzgerald
Friday, 18 July 2008
Friday, 18 July 2008
Work No. 850, Or, Run, Velazquez, Run

Martin Creed, an important "conceptual" artist of our epoch, who won the Tate Prize in 2001 for his Work No. 227,  the lights going on and off. This work consisted of an empty room in which the lights kept going, at intervals, on and off. Some people weren't sure this was even art; they were of course laughingly dismissed. 

Creed was this year give a commission, sponsored by Sotheby's, to create an original work of art for the Duveen Galleries at the Tate, to be on display this summer. He finished it in record time; in fact, it hardly took any time at all to complete it, and the sophisticated and the discerning, who do not go to galleries to see Norman Rockwell or Grandma Moses, are delighted with Creed's Work No. 850.  

Work No. 850 consists of a series or relay of runners who, every 30 seconds , sprint through the gallery, apparently in it's-a-bird-it's-a-plane-it's-Superman fashion.

Oh, why?

Well, as an official statement put out by the Tate Gallery puts it, "Work No. 850 is about the purest expression of human vitality. This investigation into the body celebrates physicality and the human spirit, the constant ebb and flow of nature."

How true. And isn't that what a work of art is supposed to do, to offer "the purest expression of human vitality" and to conduct an "investigation"(not sure about exactly how this investigation part works with the running-as-fast-as-you-can-through-the-Gallery part, but I'm sure they somehow blend) "into the body" that "celebrates physicality and the human spirit," which -- in the twinkling of a comma, becomes the same thing as "the constant ebb and flow of nature."

So run, Balthus, run. Run, Matisse, run. Run, Velazquez, run. All of you, run run run, tso as to offer the purest expression of human vitality, and what's more, to celebrate physicality and the human spirit, the constant ebb and flow of nature.

Martin Creed's hired sprinters will show you how. 

And we, who are living at this hour, can only admire, can only be grateful, can only stand astonied, at the Progress of Art.

Posted on 10:04 AM by Hugh Fitzgerald
Friday, 18 July 2008
This one’s for Artemis.

There were three bands that played around East London in the mid to late 70s in particular but not solely the Ruskin Arms in East Ham.
We all know what happened to Iron Maiden. This, by special request of Artemis is what became of Angel Witch. But whatever happened to Zorro?
I still am an Iron Maiden fan and was sorry not to have been able to see them at Twickenham two weeks ago. I was never so keen on Angel Witch myself but they had their admirers.

Posted on 12:05 PM by Esmerelda Weatherwax
Friday, 18 July 2008
Morning, and Our Legal System, Has Broken
British folk singer Yusuf Islam, formerly Cat Stevens, on Friday accepted libel damages and an apology from a news agency which reported he refused to talk to women at an awards ceremony who were not wearing a veil.
The artist, who changed his name after becoming a Muslim in the late 1970s, will donate the "substantial" payout to Small Kindness, a UN-linked charity which he chairs.
Adam Tudor, the singer's solicitor, told London's High Court that the story behind the legal action was published by World Entertainment News Network and was used on Contactmusic.com, a Web site said to have 2.2 million page views a month.
The article appeared in March last year and suggested that the singer was "so sexist and bigoted that he refused at an awards ceremony to speak to or even acknowledge any women who were not wearing a veil," Tudor said.
"It went on to suggest that Mr. Islam's manager had stated 'Mr. Islam doesn't speak with women except his wife. Least of all if they don't wear a headscarf. Things like that only happen via an intermediary.'"
Tudor said the article had embarrassed the singer, creating a false impression of his attitude to women and also casting serious aspersions on his religious faith.
World Entertainment News Network issued an apology, saying:
"We now accept that these allegations ... are entirely without foundation, and that Mr. Islam has never had any difficulties working with women, whether for religious or for any other reason."
Islam, 59, is still best known for his hits as Cat Stevens, including "Wild World," "Morning Has Broken" and "Moonshadow."
He sold an estimated 60 million albums as Stevens, but retired from showbusiness in 1978 after converting to Islam. He released his first mainstream pop album since then in 2006.
 
Islam's previous 'charity', Muslim Aid, was on a 2002 watch list as 'an organisation which funds and recruits Al Qaeda Muhajideen'. The webmaster of Muslim Aid was the documented Al Qaeda operative, Asaria Iqbal.  Yusuf Islam also donated heavily to the Islamic Relief Agency (ISRA), which was designated as a terrorist 'charity' that 'provided hundreds of thousands of dollars to Osama bin Laden'. 
The "Things like that only happen via an intermediary" comment sounds pretty specific.  I believe I heard that in the U.K., unlike the U.S., truth is not a defense in a libel case.  Entertainment media, such as World Entertainment News Network, rely on keeping a cordial relationship with entertainment industrialists.  Given Yusuf Islam's connections with Sir Paul McCartney, Peter Gabriel, and others, World Entertainment News Network would have every reason to back off, regardless of whether they had an audio/video recording of the statements being made.
Posted on 1:13 PM by Artemis Gordon Glidden
Friday, 18 July 2008
Re: Cat Stevens

 I believe I heard that in the U.K., unlike the U.S., truth is not a defense in a libel case - Artemis

"Justification", i.e. that the allegation is proved to be true, is the main defence in a libel case. "True" and "proved to be true" are not the same thing - complicated rules of evidence apply. The main problem with our law is that the burden of proof is on the defendant, who must prove, in minute detail, that what he said was true. It is often very difficult to prove that the whole of an allegation is true, plus the plaintiff, especially if he's a rich Saudi, has money to pay lawyers, while the defendant often hasn't.

I think our libel laws should be changed, particularly to reduce damages and to exclude foreign litigants, but I have seen the other side. Our tabloids are notorious for making wild accusations, which can ruin the life of an ordinary person who can't fight back. That said, the laws were not intended, and shouldn't be used, to crush free speech, which is what they're doing, especially where Muslims are concerned.

In this particular case, unlike the Harry's Place one, I can't get worked up. It seems that the allegations were not true. I know that Yusuf Islam has worked with Dolly Parton, who, to be fair, doesn't show her real hair, or possibly even her real tits, but she's hardly a niqabette. Should a paper be able to tell lies about someone, even a Muslim? What if a Muslim were to libel a non-Muslim? Would it be OK for the non-Muslim to sue?

Posted on 2:38 PM by Mary Jackson
Friday, 18 July 2008
Kurdish Gang Members Convicted In Nashville

Jerry Gordon, Elizabeth Noble and I have covered the numerous problems with Iraqi refugees in Nashville. Muslim gangs are notoriously violent. This is from The Tennessean:

Two Kurdish Pride Gang members were found guilty today on charges they conspired to kill a drug dealer they suspected of robbing them.

Ako and Aso Nejad were among several people waiting in a wooded area of Edwin Warner Park in August 2006 for a person they intended to kill. Ako Nejad was also convicted on a charge of attempted second-degree murder for firing shots at a park police officer who approached the group and gave chase when the suspects took off.

The brothers face sentences of at least 15-25 years at their next hearing on Sept. 2, according to the Davidson County Attorney General’s office. Ako Nejad faces an additional 8-12 years for the attempted murder conviction.

Both men had been charged in the past on violent offenses, according to Metro police.

Aso Nejad was one of two people charged in the shooting of an 18-year-old at Glencliff High School’s graduation in 2007. Ako Nejad was arrested in October 2007 related to a shooting in Whitfield Park but the charges were dropped when witnesses didn’t come to court.

Witnesses didn't come to court because they were threatened and went into hiding.

Posted on 2:49 PM by Rebecca Bynum
Friday, 18 July 2008
UN Soldiers Salute Hezbollah

W. Thomas Smith writes in World Defense Review (thanks to Jeffrey Imm): The saluting soldiers – one wearing wearing a light-blue (United Nations color) helmet, the other a beret – are actually members of the United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon (UNIFIL).

They are saluting, of course, the Lebanese flag. But they are also saluting the remains of terrorists returning to Lebanon from Israel following the recent “swap” between Israel and the terrorist group, Hezbollah.

Notice what else they are saluting: The giant photograph on the truck bearing the terrorists’ remains is that of recently assassinated Imad Mughniyeh, the infamous Hezbollah-butcher who was responsible for blowing up the American Embassy and the U.S. Marine barracks (also a French paratrooper barracks) in Beirut in 1983 , and then torturing and murdering an unarmed American sailor in 1985. Beyond those attacks and over the years, Mughniyeh directed a series of lesser-reported kidnappings and murders against Americans and others...

Posted on 3:28 PM by Rebecca Bynum
Friday, 18 July 2008
Q & A With T. Boone Pickens

National Journal: Q: You know, you have really changed the world with your conversation about wind energy. [PickensPlan.com] is really an incredible Web site -- these videos, the ads, what you're doing. For those who haven't seen it, which means they don't live here in the United States -- but why don't you just give us a quick one minute on how you think you have the answer to the energy issue?

Pickens: OK. The problem first: We are paying now $700 billion a year for foreign oil. We're going to break the country, is what's going to happen. If we go 10 years at this, and we've been doing it for 40 -- not at that level, but we have... our imports have gone up from 24 percent in 1970 to now -- we're almost 70 percent, and by 10 years from now, in 2018, we'll be up to 80 percent. It's crazy, we're insane to do what we're doing.

OK. That's where I'm approaching the problem. Now, when I look at the solutions -- we only have one natural resource in America that can replace foreign oil, and that is natural gas. Natural gas is a better transportation fuel than gasoline, so if that's the case, it's cheaper, it's cleaner and it's a domestic resource. So we have to go to natural gas; we don't have any choice if we're going to reduce the $700 billion. And I think within less than 10 years we could reduce that by 30 to 40 percent -- the import of foreign oil.

So you know, when I see it, I see only winners here. And then I fold in a wind project to help it all, but you'll get into that on some questions here.

Q: Absolutely. In fact, let me ask you about that. Let's start with wind, because your own state of Texas yesterday agreed to a $4.9 billion plan -- now it's new transmission lines. Can you explain the transmission lines and how it works with the wind power?

Pickens: Yes, they're going to build -- that's a [unintelligible] system, that's our transmission in Texas -- and they're going to build these lines and extend it into the wind area -- which is up in the panhandle of Texas -- which will be very helpful for us.

Q: But how? I mean, if it's such an effective way, why wasn't it done before?

Pickens: Listen, that is a question you can ask about the problems with energy in America. I mean, why wasn't it done before? For 40 years, Tammy, 40 years, we have had no leadership on energy in this country. Can you imagine that we drifted, drifted, drifted like we have, and we're so dependent on foreign oil? You know, it's the same thing; government moves very slow, as you know, and they are reactive instead of proactive. Government is not like business and industry is.

Q: So business right now has to push and prod governments to get into this?

Pickens: What we've got to do, is we've got to come up with some leadership in Washington that recognizes the problem and you know, then has a plan, and they tell us this is what we're going to do, because the American people are fed up with this...

Posted on 4:41 PM by Rebecca Bynum
Friday, 18 July 2008
Rich Pickens

I have a bone to pick with T. Boone Pickens - and there's a lot at steak.

Can that be his real name? Does he know Sir Jock Stirrup and the other muckamucks with monickers to match?

Posted on 5:08 PM by Mary Jackson
Friday, 18 July 2008
'Time' Publishes Definitive Obama Puff Piece

The Onion:

NEW YORK—Hailed by media critics as the fluffiest, most toothless, and softest-hitting coverage of the presidential candidate to date, a story in this week's Time magazine is being called the definitive Barack Obama puff piece.

"No news publication has dared to barely scratch the surface like this before," columnist and campaign reporter Michael King wrote in The Washington Post Tuesday. "This profile sets a benchmark for mindless filler by which all other features about Sen. Obama will now be judged. Just impressive puff-journalism all around."

The 24-page profile, entitled "Boogyin' With Barack," hit newsstands Monday and contains photos of the candidate as a baby, graduating from Columbia University, standing and laughing, holding hands with his wife and best friend, Michelle, greeting a crowd of blue-collar autoworkers, eating breakfast with diner patrons, and staring pensively out of an airplane window while a pen and legal pad rest comfortably on his lowered tray table.

According to political analysts, the Time piece features the most lack-of-depth reporting on Obama ever published, and for the first time reveals a number of inconsequential truths about the candidate, including how he keeps in shape on the campaign trail, and which historical figures the presidential hopeful would choose to have dinner with.

"The sheer breadth of fluff in this story is something to be marveled at," New York Times Washington bureau chief Dean Baquet said. "It's all here. Favorite books, movies, meals, and seasons of the year ranked one through four. Sure, we asked Obama what his favorite ice cream was, but Time did us one better and asked, 'What's your favorite ice cream, really?'"

Time managing editor Rich Stengel said he was proud of the Obama puff piece, and that he hoped it would help to redefine the boundaries of journalistic drivel.

"When the American people cast their vote this November, this is the piece of fluff they're going to remember," Stengel said. "Not the ones by Newsweek, Harper's, The New Yorker, The Atlantic, The New Republic, The Economist, Nightline, The Wall Street Journal, or even that story about lessons Obama learned from his first-grade teacher we ran a month ago."...

Posted on 7:14 PM by Rebecca Bynum
Friday, 18 July 2008
Carrying Out Shari'a

Here is video of the execution of two women said to be prostitutes in Afghanistan.

Posted on 8:45 PM by Rebecca Bynum
Most Recent Posts at The Iconoclast
Search The Iconoclast
Enter text, Go to search:
 
The Iconoclast Posts by Author
The Iconoclast Archives
sun mon tue wed thu fri sat
   1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31   

RSS Site Feed
RSS Feed