Tuesday, 12 February 2013
From National Review On-Line:
Feb. 11, 2013
Last October, someone by the name of Abdullatif al-Mulhim wrote an article that broke a taboo. He told fellow Arabs something they are never allowed to hear, that their wars against Israel have only harmed themselves. Hostility towards Israel is almost sacrosanct in Arab countries, and learned men on public platforms solemnly assert that Jews are descendants of apes and pigs. It is dangerous to keep people in ignorance like this. The real enemies of the Arabs, Mulhim spells out, are corruption, lack of good education and health care, and so lack of respect for human life. Arab dictators, he goes on, have committed atrocities against their own people far worse than all the full-scale Arab-Israeli wars. What decided him to write like this was starvation, killing, and destruction in one or another Arab country. The final clincher is that Palestinians in Israel or under occupation in the West Bank and Gaza are happier and in a better situation than their Arab brothers who came to liberate them.
I know nothing about Mulhim except that he is described as a retired officer of the Saudi navy. And now Amal al-Hazzani publishes two articles with similar observations. She is Assistant Professor of Molecular Genetics at King Saud University in Riyadh with quite a list of contributions to professional journals to her credit. In Israel, she writes, “politicians are distinguished by their sincerity and devotion to the higher interests of the state.” Arabs listen to the cheap words of poets and politicians who heap insults on Israel from their luxurious hotel rooms. They are still unaware where, why, and how their feelings of hate towards Israel come about. While they have sunk into hating, the Israelis have built eight public universities and 200 museums and become a rival to America in the programming and software industry. Israelis have got where they are by intelligence, or as she explains, by learning Arabic and studying the culture of Arabs. Her admiration for these achievements is clear.
The Middle East is exploding and the explanation for these articles may lie in the rivalry between Saudi Arabia and Iran, that is to say Sunni versus Shiite, or Arab versus Persian. The Saudis are frightened of the imminent finalization of an Iranian nuclear bomb and they see President Obama as weak, variable, more likely to surrender rather than use military measures to stop the nuclear threat. Israel would certainly take military measures and so there is a coincidence of interests. The Arab press is controlled, and it may be that the ground is being prepared for welcoming a strike. As far as I know, neither has been pressured by authorities, let alone punished. Both of these writers may also be free spirits with the courage of their opinions. If ever the word gets out to the masses that hatred of Israel is irrational and counterproductive then there will be a repeat of perestroika and the Arab Spring will become a reality.
Comment: Even if there not two examples, but two thousand, or two hundred thousand, of Muslim Arabs wiling to see Israel as not the villain and center of conpsiracies against Arabs and Muslims, nor as an offense against Allah and Muhammad and all that is good and right and just, still there remains Islam, the texts of islam. And a billion or so Muslims are not likely to reach a stage of enlightenment that will allow them to overlook those texts.
Still, a few examples such as this, where reality has broken through, are heartwarming. So enjoy them. Dream. But don't base any policies on these examples. That would be like Obama, who famously said that he was putting his money "on the Google boy" -- that is, Waed Ghonem, who was depicted, not quite accurately, as an example of Thoroughly Modern Egypt (apparently, being a Middle East marketer for Google made him practically a Muslim Robert Noyce or Steve Jobs or Sergey Brin), which was inevitably Going To Win because the wael-ghonems of this world were, just like Obama and Hillary Clinton, on the Right Side of History.
Posted on 02/12/2013 7:00 AM by Hugh Fitzgerald
12 Feb 2013
Unfortunately, the Not So Great Expectations and the Great Brown Hope are more broadly thriving in the West than one might think and, on at least one important level, seem to reflect no significant difference in this regard between the "Counter-Jihad" and those out in the sunshine and wide open spaces of the mainstream.