Saturday, 16 February 2013
Like Stalin With Marshal Tukhachevsky, Erdogan Seems Hell-Bent On Destroying His Military

From Reuters:

Turkish officer resignations fuel fears over army morale

 Feb 7 2013

By Jonathon Burch

ANKARA (Reuters) - Scores of Turkish air force officers have quit since the start of the year, according to opposition lawmakers and media reports, a further sign of weak morale after a top naval commander quit over the jailing of hundreds of his colleagues.

Turkey has detained several hundred serving and retired officers in recent years under Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan, including as many as a fifth of its top military chiefs, on charges of conspiring to overthrow the government.

The cases are part of an effort by Erdogan, in power for a decade, to stamp out "anti-democratic forces" and bring to heel the once-supreme military, which regularly interfered in politics and staged three outright coups in 1960, 1971 and 1980.

But the detentions have sapped morale in NATO's second-biggest army, which has been fighting a three-decade-old insurgency against Kurdish militants in the southeast and trying to prevent a spillover of the civil war in neighboring Syria.

The latest reported resignations by 110 air force officers prompted a statement from the office of the chief of general staff, which rarely talks to the media, refuting suggestions that the military had been weakened.

"Because of the dynamic and institutional structure of the Turkish armed forces, any staff member who departs is replaced with another staff member with the same qualification," it said.

January and February were the normal period for military officers to submit voluntary resignations or early retirement requests, the statement said.

Erdogan said late on Wednesday the departures were routine and described suggestions the army had been weakened as "ugly", although he acknowledged last month that lengthy pre-trial detentions were sapping army morale, an apparent bid to distance himself from increasingly unpopular coup trials.

More than 300 past and present officers were handed lengthy prison sentences in September after a 21-month trial on charges of plotting to topple Erdogan's government almost a decade ago.

Hundreds more officers are still on trial in various conspiracy cases and around 37, more than 10 percent, of the 348 generals and admirals in the Turkish armed forces are in jail.

U.S. Ambassador Francis Ricciardone was quoted by a Turkish newspaper this week as criticizing the jailing of military leaders. The Foreign Ministry said it had told the U.S. envoy in a meeting on Wednesday that such comments were "unacceptable".

Admiral Nusret Guner, who was operational commander of Turkey's navy, said last month the conspiracy cases and jailings of his colleagues had driven him to quit and that he had feared he would become the next victim. Guner had been due to take over the navy's top role later this year.

Erdogan has received praise at home and abroad for bringing the military under civilian control.

But the years that defendants spend in prison without conviction have raised suspicions the conspiracy trials are aimed at muzzling opposition, with even some sympathizers saying the number of officers charged has spiraled out of control.

About 100 journalists are also in prison, as well as thousands of activists, lawyers, politicians and others. Most are accused of plotting against the government or supporting outlawed Kurdish militants.

Just before the war with the Nazis, in the late 1930s, Joseph Stalin not only staged -- with a little help from Andrey Vyshinsky -- the show-trials of the "wreckers" -- "wreckers" that is of the great Soviet nation, and its economic achievements, political stability, and so on -- which were aimed at destroying, in every sense, his rivals among the Old Bolsheviks, including Kamenev, Zinoviev, Bukharin, and many others.

And at the same time, Stalin decided to purge the Red Army of all those whom for one reason or another he deemed potential threats to his despotism. The most important of these threats, in Stalin's view, was Marshal Tukhachevsky -- someone whom he had been thinking about getting rid of ever for many years.  He alsow decided to rid himself of seven other high-ranking officers. And later on, most of the generals who passed the death sentence on Tukhachevsky were themselves executed.

The effect was that, when the Wehrmacht came a-calling, as many, but not Stalin (a blend of the paranoid and, when it came to Mr. Hitler, far  too trusting)  knew it would, the Red Army, its officer corps decimated just a few years before, was ill-prepared.

The Turkish army, the Turkish navy, the Turkish air force -- that is, the military -- has been the historic protector of Kemalism. There is plenty to criticize. Some of its officers have at times been too intent on ruthlessly upholding the Replacement Theology (with Ataturk becoming the center of a cult, as a substitute for Muhammad, and the "Turks, the Sun People" " replacing Muslims as "the best of peoples") as an attempt to sate the emotional needs of those in Turkey, among its masses, who Need To Believe. But it also included many who, in upholding the systematic constraints on Islam as a social and political force, made possible those reedoms, inner and outer, that Turks -- including their critics, who may now come to regret the undermining of the military's power -- enjoyed, freedoms which have not as yet been  extinguished by Erdogan, but not for want of trying.

Turks themselves can consider if what Erdogan has wrought in any way reminds  them of what Stalin did to Marshal Tukhachevsky and his fellow generals. 

Posted on 02/16/2013 8:44 AM by Hugh Fitzgerald
No comments yet.

Join leaders of the American Middle Eastern community to endorse

Donald J. Trump
for President of the United States

and spend an evening with his foreign policy advisors featuring
Dr. Walid Phares
and other surprise campaign guests.

Monday October 17th

Omni Shoreham Hotel
2500 Calvert Street Northwest
Washington, DC 20008

cocktails at 6pm - dinner at 7pm
Business casual attire

$150 per person / $1500 per table

Sponsored by the American Mideast Coalition for Trump

Buy Tickets