If you see this text then you need to update your flash player.

Print this pagePrint this page.

Recent Publications by New English Review Authors
In Praise of Prejudice: The Necessity of Preconceived Ideas
by Theodore Dalrymple
Defending The West:
by Ibn Warraq
Nations, Language and Citizenship:
by Norman Berdichevsky
Romancing Opiates
by Theodore Dalrymple
Which Koran?
by Ibn Warraq
Our Culture, What's Left of It
by Theodore Dalrymple
What The Koran Really Says
by Ibn Warraq
Life at the Bottom
by Theodore Dalrymple
The Origins of the Koran
by Ibn Warraq
Why I Am Not Muslim
by Ibn Warraq
Spanish Vignettes: An Offbeat Look Into Spain's Culture, Society & History
by Norman Berdichevsky
Leaving Islam
Edited by Ibn Warraq
Friday, 4 July 2008
That Ravishing Valley, That Chugging Choo-Choo

Entrusted with the task of finding a painting for the somer season, when soft was the sun, I hit upon George Inness’s railroad-commissioned painting, in 1855, of the Lackawanna Valley. It's at the site's main page. It can't be missed. It depicts a steam engine making its way up the slow incline of the Lackawanna Valley, headed  not directly toward the viewer, in what is still placid green, still largely free of what -- we know -- is to come. The choo-choo itself appears, without railroad cars behind it, and the smoke from its tiny engine echoes the smokestack on the roundhouse in the valley below, and the tinier smokestacks on a handful of  factories also below.

 

One is reminded of the first few illustrations in that well-known American children’s book, The Little House, those in which the Little House itself is  in the countryside, a countryside that will, as the pages turn and the story be told, be dug into, be built upon, and then built up upon, more and more and more, and the sky darken, and the roads and cars appear, and then a subway system, and then apartment buildings will be constructed, on both sides of the tiny, still cheerful Little House,  now surrounded by dark smoky city surroundings, until one fine day the descendants of the original inhabitants of the Little House arrive to rescue it, which rescue consists of moving it on a flat-bed truck and taking it far far into the still-verdant and unspoiled countryside, and setting it into a spot very much like the one in which the Little House was first situated. And the moral of the story? Not clear, because we do not know, or perhaps we are not to ask, what will happen when that place, too, is built up, and built up, in the same way as before, and the country itself begins to run out of its own countryside.

 

It is the theme of relentless industrialization, or rather of what Louis Marx called The Machine in the Garden. There’s the choo-choo (that’s the Machine) and there is that  how-green-were-my-valleys valley of the languid Lackawanna (that's the Garden). Indeed, in Louis Marx’s book, this painting – I discovered after it was put up here – serves as Plate 2 in "The Machine in the Garden." And I further discovered, after choosing this painting (and obtaining the agreement of the Management) that Nicolai Civosky, formerly the curator American and British Art at the National Gallery (Washington), in his own study of Inness, judged this painting to be the finest of Innesss’s earlier works and one of the finest he, Inness, ever painted. I also found and while standing in a used-book store, quickly read the long entry on “The Lackawanna Valley” in “Landscape Painting in America” by Wolfgang Born, a refugee from Nazified Vienna who published “Landscape Painting in America” in 1947 and dedicated it “To The Memory of My Mother,” a dedication which made flit across my brain the uneasy thought of the not-inconceivable inconceivable circumstances of his mother’s death. Born describes how Inness has deliberately lightened up things, in an example of what might be called Luminism avant la lettre.

 

The Choo-Choo or, as such narrow-guage steam engines are called in Russia, Kukushka,  choo-choos its way, a Little Engine That Could, across the landscape. It hasn’t yet grown to full estate; the valley in question has already begun to yield the coal in the groaning seams below – and across the state, at the same latitude – sits Titusville, and an even more sinister discovery, that of oil.

 

But in the world of the painting in the world of the painting. No one yet senses what is inevitabaly to come, or how that very Lackawanna Valley might yield all of its green thoughts, and green shade, to smoky Scranton (and out-of-work Scranton, in turn, will become in the minds of other, still much later,  viewers not a real place, but the mythical home of Dunder Mifflin, that cross the comedy writers bear between Dunster House and Houghton Mifflin).

 

And right now, when we see that Little Steam Engine That Could, we are not hysteron-proteronically fearful of what’s to come, as we might have been twenty years ago, or fifty, but instead fond of the little fellow, and wish him well, and hope that trains make that comeback they so richly deserve, and put the automobile back in its place.

Why, some of us may even make a mental note to ourselves that if we ever travel to Russia, we must go and visit the Narrow-Gauge Railway Museum in Pereslavl where, for all I know, working at the museum or living in the city of that museum, the one  that contains old parovozy, steam engines, and displays exhibits devoted to celebrated choo-choos and kukushki, may perhaps be relatives of Nicolai Cikovsky and, come to think of it, of Wolfgang Born too -- both of them examples of immigrants who, true refugees, from Nazis and from Communists, were uncomplicatedly loyal to this country, and though they did not do it for that reason,  in becoming gifted and learned students and connnoisseurs of American art, expressed their gratitude, year-round and not just on July 4, to this country and to what counts the most in preserving the liberty that attracted to this country its best and most deserving immigrants, that is, the Constitution composed by some political geniuses in Philadelphia whose like, alas, has not been seen again.  

Posted on 1:40 PM by Hugh Fitzgerald
Comments
4 Jul 2008
Artemis Gordon Glidden

Based on the title, this article could have gone in many different directions, perhaps even in a tunnel or two.

But, yes, I'll sip a lemonade in honor of the immigrants who have made this great country what it is, and in honor of the men and women serving overseas who, despite the best efforts of the Commander in Chief, manage to keep us safe.



4 Jul 2008
John M. J.

Lackawanna Valley and its importance was explained to me some years by ago Jim Potter, at that time lately retired from a prominent position at the LSE where he lectured in American Economics and all things American - I have some signed first editions of his excellent books on my shelves.  I well remember that wonderful late summer afternoon sitting after lunch in his dining room and sipping an excellent post-prandial whisky whilst gazing out over his immaculately manicured garden.

I remember it so well because I had just asked him a question about the importance of the Marshall Plan and how much it might have meant to Americans and received from him an outpouring of knowledge so vast and so deep that I was impressed despite myself. He delved back and back into American economic history and reached the importance of the Lackawanna Valley outlined it and then summed up what he had said, drew connexions between all the facts and reached his elegant and well reasoned conclusion. He did it all in fifteen or twenty minutes without having to consult notes or books or some idiot computer. I had my answer and it was comprehensive and thorough.

For me any mention of the Lackawanna Valley will always remind me of how a gentleman and a scholar should answer a serious question asked by another - comfortably, quietly  and with reason, and at a pace that the listener can cope with.

And, of course, with a glass of fine old Scotch readily to hand!



Most Recent Posts at The Iconoclast
Search The Iconoclast
Enter text, Go to search:
 
The Iconoclast Posts by Author
The Iconoclast Archives
sun mon tue wed thu fri sat
    1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31  

RSS Site Feed
RSS Feed