Ettinger: Purimfest 1946 and other commentary from The Purim Guide for the Perplexed
Purim Shpiel Hamenntaschen
Purim began tonight with the reading of the Megillah or Book of Esther. Purim comes from the ancient Akkadian word for Pur or “lots”. Legend has it that Esther was selected to succeed Queen Vashti, who defied her husband, marrying Ahasuerus (Xerxes) the ancient King of the vast Persian Empire. She saved her fellow Jews with information from her uncle Mordechai about a plot by a royal vizier, Haman to destroy them. Haman and his ten sons were then hanged on orders of Ahasuerus; the empire’s Jews were warned, armed themselves and defeated their enemies. Esther’s Uncle Mordechai was rewarded and made a vizier by Ahasuerus to replace Haman.
During the celebration of Purim Jews are encouraged to wear costumes and spin groggers (noisemakers) during the reading of the Book of Esther at the mere mention of the name of Haman. Haman the Agagite conspired to commit genocide against the Jews was an alleged descendent of the fabled Amalek. Jews celebrate Purim with special food (Hamentaschen- three cornered confectionaries with sweet filings), encouraged to imbibe and perform Purimshpiel funny skits rejoicing at their deliverance replete with the equivalent of April Fools jokes.
In synagogue today Jews read from a portion of the torah where the Prophet Samuel admonishes King Saul for showing mercy to Agag, the Amalekite king thereby losing G-d’s favor and his kingship. Samuel then commands that Agag be brought before him and kills him. This is a warning to Jews about Amalek, who began by attacking defenseless women, children and stragglers during the Exodus from Egypt. Amalekites may have been descendents of the Biblical Esau and hence Ishmaelites. Three of the 613 commandants observed by Orthodox Jews require them to remember what the Amalekites did to Jews, and to destroy the Amalekites and their descendents throughout the millennia, utterly.
Former Israeli Ambassador (ret.) Yoram Ettinger, who spoke in Pensacola over Presidents Day Weekend , is mid-way in an itinerary that has taken him to Washington, DC, ad Denver, and hence onto Casper, ,Portland, Austin, Wichita Falls, El Paso and Chicago, before heading back to Israel. He still had time to author a fascinating discourse, based on Jewish Sages “Purim Guide for the Perplexed. “
1. "Purimfest 1946” were the last words of Julius Streicher, the Nazi propaganda chief, as he approached the hanging gallows (Newsweek magazine, October 28, 1946, page 46). On October 16, 1946 (Jewish year 5707), tenconvicted Nazi war criminals were hanged in Nuremberg. An 11th Nazi criminal, Hermann Goering, committed suicide in his cell. Julius Streicher's library documented much interest in Purim and its relevance to enemies of the Jewish people.
According to the Scroll of Esther, King Ahasuerus allowed the Jews to defend themselves and hang Haman and his ten sons. The Talmud (Megillah 16a) claims that Haman had an 11th child, a daughter, who committed suicide following her father's demise.
2. Purim's historical background according to Prof. Israel Eldad:
*Xerxes the Great – King Ahasuerus, known for his grand and long banquets – succeeded Darius the Great. He ruled the Persian Empire (from India to Ethiopia) during 465-486BC, 150 years before the rise of Alexander the Great, who defeated the Persian Empire.
*Greece was Persia's key opponent in its expansion towards the Mediterranean and Europe, hence the alliance between Persia and Carthage, a rival of Greece.
*Greece supported Egypt's revolt against Persian rule, which was subdued by Persia with the help of the Jewish warriors of Yeb (in Egypt) and Carthage, which had a significant Jewish-Hebrew connection (the names of Carthage's heroes, Hannibal and Barca, derived from the Hebrew names, Hananyah and Barak).
*Xerxes was defeated by Greece at the battle of Salamis (480 BC), but challenged Greece again in 470BC.
*According to a Greek translation of the Scroll of Esther, Haman (the Agagi) was Macedonian by orientation or by birth. Agagi could refer to Agag, the Amalekite King (who intended to annihilate the Jews) or to the Greek Aegean Islands. Haman aspired to annihilate the Jews of Persia and opposed improved relations between Xerxes and the Jews of Yeb. He led the pro-Greek and anti-Carthage faction in Persia, while Mordechai was a chief advocate for the pro-Carthage orientation.
3. Purim is celebrated on the 14th/15th days of the Jewish month of Adar. Adar (×�×“×¨) is the root of the Hebrew adjective Adir (- (×�×“×™×¨ glorious, awesome, exalted, magnificent. It is, also, a derivative of the Akkadian word Adura (heroism). Jewish tradition (Babylonian Talmud) highlights Adar as a month of happiness, singing and dancing. The zodiac of Adar is Pisces (fish), which is a symbol of demographic multiplication. Hence, Adar is the only Jewish month, which doubles itself during the 7 leap years, in each 19 year cycle. Purim is celebrated on the 14th (in non-walled towns) and (in Jerusalem) on the 15th day of Adar, commemorating thedeliverance of the Jewish People from the jaws of a holocaust in Persia. It also commemorates the 161 BC victory of Judah the Maccabee over Nikanor, the Assyrian commander. Moses ¬ who delivered the Jewish People from a holocaust in Egypt and whose burial site is unknown - was born, and died (1273 BC), on the 7th day of Adar, which is Israel's Memorial Day for soldiers, whose burial site is unknown. The events of Purim occurred following the destruction of the 1st Temple by Nebuchadnezzar (586 BCE) and the exile from Zion, during the leadership of Ezra who returned to Jerusalem, and the inauguration of the Second Temple (3rd of Adar, 515 BCE) by Ezra and Nehemiah. Nebuchadnezzar died in Adar 561 BC (Jeremiah 52:31). Albert Einstein published the Theory of General Relativity in Adar 1916.
4. Purim's Hebrew root is fate/destiny (×¤×•×¨), as well as "lottery" (commemorating Haman's lottery which determined the designated day for the planned annihilation of the Jewish People), "to frustrate,” "to annul” (×œ×”×¤×¨), "to crumble” and "to shutter” (×œ×¤×•×¨×¨), reflecting the demise of Haman.
5. Purim commemorates a Clash of Civilizations between Mordechai the Jew and Haman the Iranian-Amalekite. It constitutes an early edition of the war between right VS wrong, liberty VS tyranny, justice VS evil, truth VS lies, as were/are Adam/Eve VS the snake, Abel VS Cain, Abraham VS Sodom and Gomorrah, Jacob VS Esau (grandfather of Amalek), Maccabees VS Assyrians, Allies VS Nazis, Western democracies VS Communist Bloc and Western democracies VS Islamic rogue and terrorist regimes.
6. Purim is the holiday of contradictions as well as tenacity-driven-optimism:
Annihilation replaced by deliverance; Esther's concealment of her Jewish identity replaced by the disclosure of her national/religious identity; Haman's intended genocide of the Jews replaced by his own demise; Haman replaced by Mordechai as the chief advisor to the king; national and personal pessimism replaced by optimism. A Purim lesson: Life is complex, full of contradictions, ups and downs and difficult dilemmas, worthy of principled-determination. Threats and hurdles are challenges and opportunities in disguise. The bigger the mission is, the bigger the adversity.
7. Mordechai, the hero of Purim and one of Ezra's deputies, was a role model of principle-driven optimism in defiance of colossal odds, in the face of a super power and in defiance of the Jewish establishment. He fought Jewish assimilation and urged Jews to sustain their roots and return to their Homeland. He was endowed with the bravery of faith-driven individuals, such as Nachshon - who was the first to walk into the Red Sea before it parted. Mordechai was a politically-incorrect, out-of-the-box thinking statesman and a retired military leader, who utilized a "disproportionate pre-emptive offensive” instead of appeasement and defense. The first three Hebrew letters of Mordechai (×ž×¨×“×›×™) spell the Hebrew word "rebellion” (×ž×¨×“), which is consistent with the motto/legacy of John Adams, Thomas Jefferson and Benjamin Franklin: "Rebellion against Tyrants is Obedience to G-D." Mordechai did not bow to Haman, the second most powerful person in the Persian Empire. He was a member of the tribe of Benjamin, the only son of Jacob who did not bow to Esau. The name Mordechai is also a derivative of Mordouch, ¬ the chief Babylonian god.
Mordechai was a descendant of King Saul, who defied a clear commandment (to eradicate the Amalekites). He spared the life of Agag, the Amalekite king, thus precipitating further calamities upon the Jewish People. Consequently, Saul lost his royal position and life. Mordechai learned from Saul's error. He destroyed Haman, a descendant of Agag the Amalekite and Haman's entire power base, thus sparing the Jewish People a major disaster.
In Gimatriya, "Cursed Haman" (×�×¨×•×¨×”×ž×Ÿ) equals 502, which is identical to "Blessed Mordechai”. (×‘×¨×•×š×ž×¨×“×›×™)
8. Queen Esther, the heroine of Purim's Scroll of Esther (the 24th and concluding book of the Bible) was Mordechai's niece. Esther demonstrates the centrality of women in Judaism, shaping the future of the Jewish People, as did Sarah, Rebecca, and Rachel. Leah, Miriam, Batyah, Deborah, Hannah, Yael, etc. Sarah was the first Jewish woman, and Esther was the last Jewish woman mentioned in the Bible. Sarah lived 127 years and Esther ruled over 127 countries. The name Esther (×�×¡×ª×¨) is a derivative of the Hebrew word ×”×¡×ª×¨, "to conceal" - reflective of her initial concealment of her Jewish identity, while the Hebrew word for "scroll,” ×ž×’×™×œ×”, derives from ×ž×’×™×œ×” – "to reveal.” God is concealed in the scroll of Esther, which is the only biblical book which does not mention God. The Purim custom of wearing costumes highlights the transition from the concealment to revelation of identity.
The name Esther (pronounced Ester in Hebrew) derives also from Ishtar ¬ a Mesopotamian goddess, Astarte, "star” ¬ a Phoenician goddess. In fact, the one day pre-Purim Fastof Esther (commemorating the three day fast declared by Esther in order to expedite deliverance), was cherished by the Maranos in Spain, who performed Judaism in a clandestine manner. While God's name is hidden/absent in Esther's Scroll, Michael Bernstein suggests that there are 182 references to "King," corresponding to 26 (the numerical value of God) times 7 (days of creation). Esther's second name was Hadassah, whose root is Hadass (myrtle tree in Hebrew) ¬ whose leaves are shaped like an eye.
The name Esther is identified with the planet Venus (hence, Esther's other Hebrew name ¬Noga, just like my oldest granddaughter ¬ a shining divine light, which is Venus in Hebrew). In Gimatriya, Esther (×�×¡×ª×¨) and Noga (× ×’×”) equal 661 and 58 respectively, and the sum of 6+6+1 and 5+8 is 13 (the number of God's virtues). In "small Gimatriya" both Esther (1+6+4+2) and Noga (5+3+5) equal 13, which is also the total sum of "one” in Hebrew (×�×—×“) ¬ which represents the oneness of God, monotheism, as well as the total sum of love in Hebrew (×�×”×‘×”).
9. The Persian King appointedMordechai to be his top advisor, overruling Haman's intent to prevent the resettling of Jews in Zion, the reconstruction of the Temple and the restoration of the wall around Jerusalem. He foiled Haman's plan to exterminate the Jews. The king prospered as a result of his change of heart and escaped assassination. That was the case with Pharaoh, who escaped national collapse and starvation and rose in global prominence, once he appointed Joseph to be his deputy.
10. Purim's four commandments:
*Reading/studying the Scroll of Esther within the family, highlighting the centrality of family, education, memory and youth as the foundation of a solid future.
*Gifts to relatives, friends and strangers emphasize the importance of family, community and collective responsibility.
*Charity (at least the value of a meal) reflects compassion and communal responsibility. According to Maimonides, "there is no greater or more glorious joy than bringing joy to the poor." Purim is celebrated when Jews study the portion of the Torah, ×ª×¨×•×ž×”, which highlights giving and contributing to the other person as a means to enhance solidarity and reduce egotism.
*Celebration and Happiness sustain optimism and faith - the backbone of individuals and nations.