Italian Decency spared Jews at Ferramonti Concentration Camp During Holocaust
Moshe Sharett, the head of the Jewish Agency’s Political Department, visited the Ferramonti di Tarsia Displaced Persons’ Camp in Italy in April 1944.Source: Yad Va Shem archives
This past weekend, my friend , Baron Bodissey (Ned May) at the Gates of Vienna (GoV) sent me an article, translated from the Italian Journal, The Local , on the 70th anniversary of the liberation of an Italian concentration camp for Jews at Ferramonti di Tarsia in Calabria, Southern Italy. May asked me for a comment and the result was this GoV post, Remembering Ferramonti.
The camp at Ferramonti held 2000 Jews, mainly non-Italians. One of the first acts of decency by the Badoglio government that opted out of the Axis in September 1943 was release of Jewish and fellow Italians jailed by the Fascist regime of Mussolini. Allied occupation of Southern Italy had followed after the fall of Sicily to combined American and British forces and creation of air bases. Bases that would carry the air war to Central Europe and special operations support to Yugoslavian resistance forces across the Adriatic. Tough slogging and brutal battles would still follow the liberation of camps like Ferramonti until the Italian peninsula was liberated in early May 1945. The campaign in the Italian peninsula would become the testing ground for the Jewish Brigade in the British Army. Many in whose ranks post war would facilitate the illegal repatriation of tens of thousands of Jewish Holocaust survivors at Ferramonti and other locations in liberated Italy via the Mossad LeAliya Bet program to pre-State Israel in the British Palestine Mandate.
The picture of a visit by then Jewish Agency Political Department head Moshe Sharett and British Jewish officers to Ferramonti from the Yad Va Shem archives in April 1944 tells another important story . Sharett's presence at Ferramonti signified his involvement in establishment of the Jewish Brigade and its post war role as the underground Mossad LeAliyah Bet program that brought Jewish Holocaust survivors including some of those depicted at Ferramonti to what ultimately became the Jewish nation of Israel. Sharett, the pre-State’s Jewish Agency’s emissary became Israel’s first Foreign Minister upon Independence in May 1948. He was heavily involved with the negotiations that ended with a cease fire agreement on the Island of Rhodes in 1949.
Below is the GoV post:
I had never heard of the Ferramonti concentration camp in Calabria until a news feed article about it came in the email today. Below are excerpts from the reminiscences of a woman who went back to Ferramonti seventy years after she was interned there as a small child, as published in the Italian edition of The Local:
‘Ferramonti Was Not a Death Camp’
Thousands of Jews were imprisoned at the Ferramonti di Tarsia concentration camp in Calabria during the Second World War. But as one survivor tells The Local, it was not like other terror camps in Europe.
During a recent visit to Calabria, at the tip of southern Italy, Judith Itzhak said “every day is a good day”.
It was her response to a pleasantry about the previous day, when she visited Tarsia, the home of the former Ferramonti concentration camp, in Cosenza for the first time since 1945.
“I appreciate the fact that I’m alive,” she tells The Local.
Judith was five years old when she was freed from Ferramonti, the largest of fifteen camps set up by Italy’s dictator Benito Mussolini between 1940 and 1943.
Between 3,000 and 5,000 Jews were imprisoned at the camp as Mussolini, a key figure in the creation of fascism, cooperated with Adolf Hitler and passed racial laws in Italy.
Judith and her parents arrived at Ferramonti — an area plagued with malaria — in early 1940, when she was just 17 days old.
Her mother, who came from a wealthy family, was heavily pregnant when she and her husband fled their native Germany, with “no idea about what was going to happen, or whether they would survive”.
Prisoners slept on wooden planks in their designated barracks and were assigned a mattress, a pillow, two blankets, two sheets and a towel upon arrival, according to a report by Centro Primo Levi, a New York-based organization for Italian Jewish studies. They were also subjected to “heavy restrictions on all aspects of their personal life…initially, any form of assembly including teaching and praying was forbidden,” the report said.
The distribution of quinine — essential for the treatment of malaria — was also prohibited, although this measure was later amended, the report added.
Even though her family feared for their future, Judith says that “ending up at Ferramonti, and not another camp in Europe, is definitely something to be happy about”.
This is because Ferramonti was not like any of the other camps, Judith continues.
“Firstly, the camp was run by Italians and not Germans,” she says.
“This was a camp made to house people the Italian government didn’t know what to do with. It was not part of a plan like Germany had to annihilate the Jewish race; the whole set-up was different, it was not a death camp or labor camp.”
It was perhaps also Ferramonti’s location in Italy’s deep south, far away from Rome’s radar, that kept people safe.
People there were unaware of the atrocities happening in camps such as Auschwitz in Poland, where Judith’s father later found out his mother and sister perished. Though inmates went hungry, nobody starved, according to the Centro Primo Levi report.
Being imprisoned at Ferramonti is also believed to have saved Jews from deportation to other camps, including Auschwitz.
“There was a priest at the camp with connections to the Vatican, and he managed to block a decision to order us to be deported,” Judith says.
She puts the “fair treatment of the people and the cooperation and humanity of the situation” down to the “decency of the people from Calabria”. She also says that “persecution was far from the minds of the camp’s management, even though they were fascist.”
Though they lived under restrictions, inmates were allowed to “make the best” of their lives within the camp.
“They looked after their needs… there was a theatre, school, library and concerts. People played bridge and chess; they made life bearable.”
Young couples, who met and fell in love in the camp, also married there. Four weddings are said to have taken place, while there were 21 births.
There were also doctors and dentists among the inmates, who would help the local villagers, who in turn would assist the prisoners, such as bringing them items from Cosenza and allowing them to receive Red Cross parcels.
“Even if the conditions were not ideal, somehow we made the best of it.”
Still, Judith is quick to point out that life in the camp was “no Club Med”, however, “you couldn’t compare it to other camps in Europe.”
Perhaps the most fearful episode was when a British airplane bombed the camp after mistaking it for a German army training camp, killing one person and injuring others.
Otherwise people who died within the camp died of natural causes, Judith says.
This was how it remained until the Jews were liberated from the camp by the Allied forces in late 1943.
Judith remembers the day well, as she says it was the first time she tasted chocolate.
Most prisoners stayed at the liberated camp until 1945 as they awaited visas, but it was also the safest place for them to be.
Judith and her parents, along with some friends made within the camp, then left for Palestine.
“My father said he didn’t want to go anywhere he’d be hit in the street for being a Jew.”
Judith later went on to marry and have three children and six grandchildren.
She made the trip back to Ferramonti last week as part of a tour of “Southern Italy Through Jewish Eyes”, organized by the Italian Jewish Cultural Center of Calabria.
Judith was accompanied by her granddaughter, who remarked on the friendliness of the Calabrians, who are also credited for helping to save the Jews.
“These are the kind of people you find in southern Italy,” says Judith…
Knowing that he’d be interested in the topic, I sent the link to Jerry Gordon at New English Review. He replied with this additional information about the treatment of Jews in Italy during the Second World War:
The Ferramonti experience of Jews is not an isolated example for Italy, as the authors Susan Zuccotti and Furio Colombo wrote in The Italians and the Holocaust: Persecution, Rescue, and Survival more than four fifths of Italy’s Jews survived because of the basic humanity and decency of Italian neighbors, or fought as Partisans.
There were horrific incidents perpetrated by the retreating Nazi occupiers, such as the Ardeatine Cave massacre In Rome of several hundred Jews and other civilians in 1944. Just yesterday convicted Nazi SS Captain Erick Priebke, who ordered the massacre, died at the age of 100. The capture and internment of the tragic Nobel Laureate Primo Levi chronicled his experiences in Survival in Auschwitz.
I am reminded of an acquaintance whose Yugoslavian Jewish parents from Belgrade were fortunate to have been interned in a camp also run by the Italians. They later joined up with Tito’s partisans. The father, trained as an international lawyer, became a senior counselor at the Washington, DC legation in the 1960’s. However, they were among the very lucky Yugoslavian Jews who survived the horrors of Croatian Death Camps. Retired Hebrew University professor of Islamic, Chinese and Middle East History, Raphael Israeli, has written about this in his book, The Death Camps of Croatia. More 700,000 Jews and Serbs were murdered at the infamous Jasenovac and Jadnovo death camps by Fascist Ustashi Croats, Chetniks, Serbian collaborators and Bosnian Muslim Waffen SS Handschar Division members.
For further reading about the death camps of Croatia, I highly recommend Ustaša by Srdja Trifkovic. Dr. Trifkovic covers the Jewish victims of the Ustaša in addition to the Serbian holocaust.