Please Help New English Review
For our donors from the UK:
New English Review
New English Review Facebook Group
Follow New English Review On Twitter
Recent Publications by New English Review Authors
As Far As The Eye Can See
by Moshe Dann
Threats of Pain and Ruin
by Theodore Dalrymple
The Oil Cringe of the West: The Collected Essays and Reviews of J.B. Kelly Vol. 2
edited by S.B. Kelly
The Impact of Islam
by Emmet Scott
Sir Walter Scott's Crusades and Other Fantasies
by Ibn Warraq
Fighting the Retreat from Arabia and the Gulf: The Collected Essays and Reviews of J.B. Kelly. Vol. 1
edited by S.B. Kelly
The Literary Culture of France
by J. E. G. Dixon
Hamlet Made Simple and Other Essays
by David P. Gontar
Farewell Fear
by Theodore Dalrymple
The Eagle and The Bible: Lessons in Liberty from Holy Writ
by Kenneth Hanson
The West Speaks
interviews by Jerry Gordon
Mohammed and Charlemagne Revisited: The History of a Controversy
Emmet Scott
Why the West is Best: A Muslim Apostate's Defense of Liberal Democracy
Ibn Warraq
Anything Goes
by Theodore Dalrymple
Karimi Hotel
De Nidra Poller
The Left is Seldom Right
by Norman Berdichevsky
Allah is Dead: Why Islam is Not a Religion
by Rebecca Bynum
Virgins? What Virgins?: And Other Essays
by Ibn Warraq
An Introduction to Danish Culture
by Norman Berdichevsky
The New Vichy Syndrome:
by Theodore Dalrymple
Jihad and Genocide
by Richard L. Rubenstein
Spanish Vignettes: An Offbeat Look Into Spain's Culture, Society & History
by Norman Berdichevsky














Tuesday, 21 October 2014
Taliban Spokesman Out For Abandoning Mullah Omar
clear

Mullah Omar won't brook those who pledge allegiance to the flag of the Islamic State, and to the caliphate for which it stands.

Story here.

clear
Posted on 10/21/2014 5:26 PM by Hugh Fitzgerald
clear
Tuesday, 21 October 2014
Islamic State Proudly Films The Lapidation Of A Woman Near Hama
clear

And her father, rejecting her appeals for help, took part, and apparently with a large rock, delivered the death blow. Of course neither Saudi Arabia, nor Iran, can protest or even pretend to protest. A few other Muslim countries can, with various degrees of implausibility and tortuous reasoning. For what are they going to do -- call such a practice a violation of Islam? Must the comedy be repeated, and yet again the supporting texts, either in Qur'an or Hadith or often, in both, be adduced?

Here.

clear
Posted on 10/21/2014 3:55 PM by Hugh Fitzgerald
clear
Tuesday, 21 October 2014
Yet Another Rampage By Murderous Muslims In China
clear
clear
Posted on 10/21/2014 3:42 PM by Hugh Fitzgerald
clear
Tuesday, 21 October 2014
Have The Syrian Kurds turned Kobani into ‘Stalingrad’ in the War against ISIS?
clear

 

Syrian Kurdish Women YPG Fighters

Source The Daily Mail

Sunday, October 19, 2014,  three USAF C-130’s flew over the Syrian  Kurdish YPG- held Western area of embattled Kobani.  Air  crews dropped 27 bundles of much needed arms, ammunition and medical supplies. Only one bundle went awry and was promptly destroyed by an accompanying coalition air fighter escort.  An NPR report noted  the importance of this successful air drop and rising level of air strikes punishing besieging ISIS Jihadists:

In a statement, U.S. Central Command said the airdrops, executed by three C-130 cargo planes, were intended to help Kurdish fighters defend the city against the group calling itself the Islamic State.

"This assistance is another example of U.S. resolve to deny ISIL key terrain and safe haven as well as our commitment to assist those forces who oppose ISIL," CENTCOM said in the statement, using a widely-used acronym for the Islamic State.

Polat Can, a spokesman for Kurdish forces in Kobani, acknowledged the delivery on his Twitter feed and added that he would soon be posting some "good news."

In the past two weeks, U.S. forces have conducted 135 airstrikes against ISIL in and around the city of Kobani. The CENTCOM statement says the strikes have killed hundreds of fighters for the Islamic State and badly degraded the group's military resources.

In a Pentagon briefing  CENTCOMM commander Gen. Lloyd J. Austin stated that despite stepped-up strategies and efforts by allied forces, "Kobani could still fall."  

Others have called the defense of Kobani by YPG forces as “very impressive”. Impressive because of the grit, determination and valorous sacrifices of Kurdish fighters with some mixed units led by women commanders.  The YPG fighters’  motivation is to stave off the ISIS rampage from conquering this outlying Syrian bastion of their  ancestral Kurdish homeland crossing the borders of neighboring Turkey, Iraq and Iran.  Kobani has not been completely overtaken  by ISIS in the more than two months siege now in the brutal urban warfare phase. It has become a symbol of armed resistance  not unlike the Russian defense and ultimate victory over the  German Sixth Army at Stalingrad in early 1943.  The Kurdish resistance in Kobani  could be the turning point in the War against ISIS if properly supported by the Coalition.  This despite the obduracy of Turkish President Recep Erdogan, whose tanks silently stand on the border at Suruc overlooking the Kobani battle ground. 

Erdogan is fearful that providing weapons and support to the YPG forces in Kobani would inflame the outrage of PKK allies in adjacent  Southeastern Turkey whose towns have been placed under virtual military control with  dozens of protesters killed. That set off street battles between Kurdish émigrés and ISIS supporters in Hamburg, Germany.  There have been protests at the White House by American Kurds and their supporters  requesting  President Obama  to support  those YPG fighters in Syria and Peshmerga in Iraq.  Support  also came from the  Kurdish Jewish community in Israel. The Times of Israel reported attendees at the annual  Saharanah festival denouncing ISIS and Turkey, “Concern for Brethren  in Syria marks Kurdish Jews Celebration”.    Yehuda ben Yosef, chairman of the National Organization of Kurdish Jews said:

This year, we focused an important part of the celebrations to call on the Israeli government and  the US, to denounce  two-faced Turkey, which doesn’t allow aid to reach the Kurdish army fighting there.  Genocide is being carried out on its borders, which are NATO borders. This is unbelievable. It’s as if the Holocaust is starting to return, and the world stands there silently.

 The US Administration was forced by public opinion outraged by the barbaric ISIS beheadings of Americans and British that fed into concern over support for  the Kurdish defense of Kobani.  Those developments forced President Obama to form a coalition of air contingents from several Sunni countries in the Middle East and the Persian Gulf that morphed into Operation Inherent Resolve. If that resolve is inherent in the battle against ISIS it is in the Syrian Kurdish YPG and Iraqi Peshmerga forces putting their lives on the line. Those Kurdish fighters communicated a message we haven’t heard since the dark days of WWII in May 1940 when Sir Winston Churchill was appointed as wartime Prime Minister, “give us tools and we’ll get the job done”.

Faith Mc Donnell of the Washington, DC-based Institute for Religion and Democracy drew attention on their blog yesterday, about the successful international social media effort led by the National Security Communications Task Force (NSCTF) of the Lisa Benson Show, “Twitter Success and Courageous Warriors”.   That was the fourth and most successful twitter rally that the NSCTF has conducted since June, 2014. The first was directed at a #DefendHamas campaign aimed at supporting Israel’s Operation Protective Edge during the 50 day rocket and terror tunnel war with Hamas in Gaza.   McDonnell wrote:

 On Thursday, October 16, activists of the National Security Communication Task Force sponsored a Twitter Rally to lobby Congress for action to stop ISIS and protect the Kurds, Christians, Yazidis, and others victimized by the brutal Islamic “State.”

Messages such as #SupportTheKurds, #SaveKobani, #DefeatISIS, #ArmTheKurds, etc. were tweeted in an effort to push for more U.S. action to stop the brutal Islamists. And even as those tweets were flying, the war against ISIS was being fought on the ground by Syrian rebels and both male and female Kurdish soldiers, as well as by unusual new reinforcements, biker gang members — from the Netherlands and Germany.

Thank you to all who joined the Twitter Rally. There were many participants tweeting seriously for the first time. Passionate about impacting U.S. Iraq/Syria/ISIS policy, their goal was to push the U.S. government into arming the only official fighting force truly standing against the caliphate-builders right now: the Kurds.

The Twitter Rally was very successful. #SupportTheKurds reached 800 tweets per hour. This particular message also trended in the National Security category.

 

McDonnell  further writes about Dutch and German bikers who left to join those courageous Kurdish defenders of Kobani with their governments’ promise that they will not be prosecuted  upon  their  return. That is unlike the thousands of ISIS wannabes who have left the West and joined up via Turkey’s jihadist highway  only to return from Syria and Iraq as dangerous homegrown terrorists. She also notes the courage of Kurdish YPG women fighters.

The last weekend edition of the Wall Street Journal on October 18-19, 2014 drew attention in a report to those YPG women fighters, who constitute one-third of the Kurdish forces defending Kobani, “Kurdish Women Battle Islamic State on Front Lines.”  One 19 year old woman fighter, “Dilar” who joined up in an all female Martyr Warsin brigade, named in honor of a fallen teacher, said, “When I walk with my gun, the men who haven’t volunteered keep their eyes down around me. My bravery shames them.” 

The valor of Kurdish women fighters in Kobani was reflected in the burial of four women near the Turkish Syrian border who fell fighting ISIS.   The courage that 'Dilar' and the fallen men and women of the YPG in Kobani have  displayed brought encouragement to other groups inside Syria fighting ISIS.  McDonnell cites Walid Phares noting the support of Christian allies of Syrian Kurds fighting in Kobani.  He stated, “The city was pronounced falling by Washington and Ankara but not by the fighters on the ground. ISIS is being pushed back by the people.” 

Watch this Wall Street Journal video on Kurdish women fighters undergoing Peshmerga training in Iraq:

While President Obama is refraining from US boots on the ground in the battle for Kobani, he needs to continually replenish those Kurdish forces  in Kobani and Peshmerga in Iraq with the “tools to finish the job”.  He should urge CENTCOMM and Coalition commanders Gens. Austin and Allen to schedule more air drops with heavier weapons and ammunition coupled with robust close air support missions to complement communications and intelligence from Kurds on the ground. Consider the casualties that the Kobani YPG fighters inflict on ISIS reported daily by the Syrian Human Observatory as retribution for ISIS beheadings of Americans James Foley and Steven Sotloff and Britons, David Haines and Alan Henning.  Perhaps, just perhaps, like Stalingrad, Kobani could demonstrate to the uncooperative Turks, President Obama and the coalition in Inherent Resolve that fighting Kurds have the resolve  to “defeat and degrade” ISIS.

clear
Posted on 10/21/2014 3:33 PM by Jerry Gordon
clear
Tuesday, 21 October 2014
Diversity: Two Antisemites, One White One Black, Announce A New Party
clear

Alain Soral, famous white antisemite, and M'bala M'bala Dieudonne, black antisemite, announce the formation of a new political party, to be called "National Reconciliation." Its headquarters are in Saint-Denis, the Muslim Arab quarter famous for its violence, and in the same building as Kontre Kulture, a semi-literate publishing house specializing in antisemitic tracts.

Story, in French, here.

clear
Posted on 10/21/2014 12:53 PM by Hugh Fitzgerald
clear
Tuesday, 21 October 2014
A Musical Interlude: Bend Down Sister (Ben Selvin Orch.)
clear

Listen here.

clear
Posted on 10/21/2014 12:26 PM by Hugh Fitzgerald
clear
Tuesday, 21 October 2014
Can You Identify The Reason You Might Be Inclined To Read This Article?
clear

The article isn't bad, but what was it, exactly, that led you to become interested in the article in the first place, and then to read it to the very end?

clear
Posted on 10/21/2014 12:15 PM by Hugh Fitzgerald
clear
Tuesday, 21 October 2014
What A Coincidence
clear

On this day in 1520 Ferdinand Magellan discovered the Strait of Magellan. Talk about coincidence!

And, while we are on the subject, I found out from a friend last week that his straitened circumstances are the result of an ill-timed investment, made a half-dozen years ago, in the Magellan Fund.

clear
Posted on 10/21/2014 11:53 AM by Hugh Fitzgerald
clear
Tuesday, 21 October 2014
Terror Attack in Quebec: Convert Runs Down and Kills Soldier
clear

Patrick Poole has gathered all the news reports:

According to multiple reports, Canadian authorities are investigating a hit-and-run and subsequent high-speed car chase this morning in St. Jean sur Richelieu in Quebec province as a possible terror attack.

CBC reports:

A man in his 30s was shot by police in Saint-Jean-sur-Richelieu, Que., earlier this afternoon after he hit two members of the Canadian Forces with his car and led police on a dramatic high-speed chase.

The soldiers were hit in a parking lot of a commercial plaza at around 11:30 a.m. ET. Both were injured, one critically.

The incident was raised in the House of Commons this afternoon by Conservative MP Randy Hoback, who questioned Prime Minister Stephen Harper about “unconfirmed reports of a possible terror attack” targeting members of the Canadian Forces.

Harper, reading from a piece of paper, would only say he was ”aware of these reports” and that they are troubling.

Police have not named the soldiers but confirmed at an afternoon news conference that they were members of the armed forces.

Another report indicates that the suspect was inside the military office beforehand talking about ISIS and may be an ISIS sympathizer.

This incident comes weeks after ISIS called for Western supporters to attack and “slaughter soldiers” in their homes. The message made suggestions for such an attack:

“Smash his head with a rock, or slaughter him with a knife, or run him over with your car, or throw him down from a high place, or choke him, or poison him.”

“If you are unable to do so, then burn his home, car, or business. Or destroy his crops. If you are unable to do so, then spit in his face.”

If this is a confirmed attack, it may be a copycat attack based off of the May 2013 killing of British Army drummer Lee Rigby on the streets of Woolwich.

UPDATE: Stewart Bell directs to this report that the suspect (who has died from his wounds) is Martin “Ahmad” Rouleau, who was known to Canadian counterterrorism authorities.

UPDATE2: Rouleau’s Facebook page is filled with caliphate imagery.

UPDATE3: Here’s a picture of Rouleau from his Ummaland (Muslim social networking site) page, where is user name was “Ahmad the Convert”:

UPDATE4: Canadian Prime Minister’s Office says that Rouleau “had become radicalized”:

“The individual who struck the two CAF members with his car is known to federal authorities, including the Integrated National Security Enforcement Team,” said the statement from Jason MacDonald, the prime minister’s spokesman.

“Federal authorities have confirmed that there are clear indications that the individual had become radicalized. As Canada’s national security agencies have said, Canadians should remain vigilant.”

UPDATE5: Stewart Bell of the National Post reports on Rouleau’s online activity:

A Twitter account under the name Ahmad Rouleau featured the banner of the Islamic State of Iraq and Al-Sham, the terrorist group that last month called on its followers to kill Canadians because of Ottawa’s role in the anti-ISIS military coalition.

“Islam is the only true religion. Anyone who want scientific proof of God that your terrorist Zionism Rothschild media hide, contact me or add me if you re open minded,” he commented beneath an online Time magazine article last May.

On a Facebook page under the same name, French and English posts — the last one on Friday — denounced Christianity and Judaism. “Allah has promised the hypocrite men and hypocrite women and the disbelievers the fire of Hell, wherein they will abide eternally. It is sufficient for them. And Allah has cursed them, and for them is an enduring punishment,” he wrote.

UPDATE6: The Toronto Sun adds this interesting tidbit:

A source says the suspect called 911 during the chase to say that he carried out his acts in the name of Allah.

And also reports:

Couture-Rouleau became known to the RCMP after a relative alerted police to the man’s terrorist leanings, a police source told QMI Agency.

A neighbor told QMI that Couture-Rouleau had grown out his beard and started wearing a turban after converting to Islam a year ago.

UPDATE7: National Post reports that one of the soldiers run down by Rouleau has died.

clear
Posted on 10/21/2014 9:31 AM by Rebecca Bynum
clear
Tuesday, 21 October 2014
Beheadings Are Up In Saudi Arabia
clear

Not everyone can come up with the Diyya, or blood money.  And those Shi'a who is guilty of promoting or taking part in protests against the Sunni government's oppression, are unlikely to be spared, for this would not be a case of simple murder, where the victim's family can choose to accept the Diyya but, rather, is a case of seditiion against the Al-Saud, and not an individual's family, but the entire state, would have to accept such Diyya and that, of course, is impossible. And besides, the Al-Saud don't need any more money.

The latest on the decapitations here.

 

clear
Posted on 10/21/2014 8:35 AM by Hugh Fitzgerald
clear
Tuesday, 21 October 2014
Michele Bachmann Threatened by Islamic State, Assigned Security Detail
clear

According to the Washington Times.

Ms. Bachmann has been a vocal opponent of the Islamic State, supporting military action against the group at the September Values Voter Summit, saying “You kill their leader. You kill their council. You kill their army until they wave the white flag of surrender,” Mediaite reported.

 

clear
Posted on 10/21/2014 7:41 AM by Rebecca Bynum
clear
Tuesday, 21 October 2014
"Now We Hate Everyone Who Prays. Now We Hate Even Beards"
clear

Here.

That's a member of the Al-Shaitat, a tribe in eastern Syria, speaking. That's the tribe of Sunni Arabs, 700 of whose members were executed by Islamic State murderers this August. Would that the expression of fury were not an exaggeration, would that some Sunni Arabs began to recognize the horror of the True Believers, and to recognize, too, that Islam itself must be attacked, and undermined, and its hold on the minds of men, and the absolute number of Believers, especially in the West if there is to be a way to count, for the world's own sanity, on that West, have to be reduced.

clear
Posted on 10/21/2014 7:16 AM by Hugh Fitzgerald
clear
Tuesday, 21 October 2014
Dimidiated Tunisia
clear

Where one-half of the population wants to be French, and the other half wants to be Saudi Arab.

Story of the beards-and-short-pants brigade now to be seen even on Avenue Bourguiba, here.

clear
Posted on 10/21/2014 12:46 AM by Hugh Fitzgerald
clear
Tuesday, 21 October 2014
A Musical Interlude: The Cop On The Beat, The Man In The Moon, And Me (Frank Luther)
clear

Listen here.

clear
Posted on 10/21/2014 12:38 AM by Hugh Fitzgerald
clear
Monday, 20 October 2014
Moorthy Muthuswamy's "Defeating Political Islam" Now An eBook
clear

A book not found, for obvious reasons, easily in bookstores, but now on eBook. Let others know.

Here.

clear
Posted on 10/20/2014 11:52 PM by Hugh Fitzgerald
clear
Monday, 20 October 2014
Magdi Allam's New Book: How Not To Lose Your Head
clear

A guide of self-defense for the peoples and polities of the West, to be published this month in Italian, and later, one hopes, in many other languages. At least, even before it is put into English, it will be the subject of Internet commentary. Sometimes the blogs begin at Calais.

About the book, here.

clear
Posted on 10/20/2014 11:26 PM by Hugh Fitzgerald
clear
Monday, 20 October 2014
Are Obama’s Approval Ratings Plummeting due to his Questionable Leadership?
clear

Publisher: Broadside Books: An Imprint of Harper Collins Publishers

Published:  October 8, 2014

ISBN: 978-0-06-234750-3

Yesterday afternoon, President Obama left the White House and with a wave of the hand to gathered journalists shouting questions about Ebola.  He was whisked away by helicopter to a high school in Maryland to attend a  gubernatorial campaign rally for Maryland’s Lt. Governor Anthony Brown. Brown  has a hefty 17 point lead over his Republican contender.  When President Obama rose to say, “You’ve got to vote”, a steady stream of likely Democratic voters walked out early.  Many of those leaving were African American voters. Their exit gave new meaning to the expression, “voting with their feet”.  That may reflect the reason he’s been out there attending fundraisers building a Senate and House campaign war chest for the 2014 midterm elections, less than 15 days away. You may recall his remarks ,people may not vote for me, but hopefully for my policies.”  According to Real Clear Politics, his overall job approval ratings hover in the low 40’s,  while falling into the low to mid’ 30’s when his foreign  policies are considered.

A number of Democratic Senate incumbents and contenders in key states have taken to avoiding any mention of him and  his so-called signature legislation, the Affordable Care Act. In the case of Kentucky Democratic Senate  candidate Ms. Alison Lundergan Grimes, she refuses to answer debate questions on whether  she cast a ballot for the President .

After his appearance at the Maryland  Democratic gubernatorial rally, the President was once again swept away by helicopter to Andrews to fly to Chicago, his home territory.  He is  to appear at rallies for Illinois  Democratic  Governor Pat Quinn and senior US Senator, Richard Durbin, both of whom are in competitive races.  Durbin has a  decreasing lead in polls against Republican Candidate dairy farmer  Jim Oberweis.   Republican gubernatorial  candidate  who is  Chairman of  Chicago Private Equity  group,  R8  Capital Partners Bruce Rauner,   is in a virtual tie  with Governor Pat Quinn.   

President Obama  is beginning to look like the Rodney Dangerfield of politics deep into his sixth  year in office.  The comedic catchphrase, “I don’t get no respect” reflects the demise of  his credibility and leadership on both domestic and foreign policy issues. Whether it is his famous  line about “ you can keep your  health plans and , the Ebola panic, and  the failure to have an effective  strategy to “degrade and destroy” the Islamic State, formerly ISIS .   It wasn’t helped by his appointment of Ron Klain,  a Democratic apparatchik, and Chief of Staff for  both Vice President Biden and former  Vice President Gore’s. He was Gore’s lawyer involved in the 2000 Presidential vote recount in Florida. Klain lacks any apparent medical expertise, but is touted for his managerial skills. This despite his deep involvement in damage control during the Solyndra insolvency.   Klain  allegedly reports to  both  Lisa Monaco, US Homeland National Security  Assistant to the President,  and  National Security Adviser Susan E. Rice. Rice has also been wounded by misstatements in the Benghazi episode and more recently on  Turkey’s  commitment to the US led coalition in the misnamed  Operation Inherent Resolve.

Obama’s lack of experience from his Illinois Senate days through his brief term as a US Senator to his two terms in the White House has  demonstrated ineffective and questiionable leadership.  It has also demonstrated something else, his all too frequent resort to  fobbing off the public with statements that don’t pass basic fact checking. Someone who has researched that  is Dr. Jack  Cashill. He is  a  conservative  journalist  and author of You Lie! The Evasions, Omissions , Fabrications, Frauds, and Outright Falsehoods of Barack Obama published on October 8th  by  Broadside Books,  an Imprint of Harper Collins Publishers.  Cashill is a veteran journalist who has written for Fortune, the Wall Street Journal, Washington Post, The Weekly Standard, AmericanThinker.com and WorldNetDaily.com.  This is his ninth and perhaps most controversial work.  The title, You Lie!  comes from the outburst  by South Carolina US. Rep. Joe Wilson during a November 2009 speech by President Obama  before a  joint session of Congress.  When President  Obama said  in his speech that   his health care reforms would not apply to immigrants who were here illegally, Wilson exclaimed, “You Lie”.  Wilson became an instant pariah from both sides of the aisle, but not among his constituents in South Carolina’s Second Congressional District. He apologized to both the President and  Republican Party leaders.  

Cashill was a guest  recently on the Sunday Lisa Benson show.  Benson asked him  how many examples where there  in his book. Cashill replied that in preparation for a New York Post  article, he counted them it was 75. There may be more to come as the President has  over two years in office left.  When  Benson asked  Cashill  what  was  Obama’s top lie, he referred to his oath of office, in which he like all Presidents promised with hand on a bible, “to faithfully execute  the office of President of the United States and will to the best of my ability , preserve, and defend the Constitution of the United States.”  To which Cashill quipped,”he better hope that God will be merciful.”  Next  was Obama’s promise that “transparency and the rule of law  will be the touchstones of the Presidency .”  Cashill opined, “ This two-headed promise has been violated more wantonly than a goat at a Taliban bachelor party.”   Third in line was what  according to Cashill  got Obama re-elected in 2012, “ If you like your doctor, you will be able to keep your doctor. Period. If you like your health plan, you will be able to keep your health plan. Period. No one will take it away. No matter what. “  Cashill rates the compound  Benghazi  lie as fourth highest, “We revealed to  the American people exactly what we understood at the time”.    

Cashill noted that  Obama’s top  25  lies he documented were  largely drawn from the pages of the Washington Post and New York Times. They over power anything  from either his predecessor George W. Bush’s whoppers to  Clinton’s,  corkers given his personal peccadilloes in public office.   Among the top 25 is what Cashill called Obama’s  genius myth.  That he wrote two books by himself which  allowed him to distance himself from his collaborator Bill Ayres.  As Cashill commented,  “Ayres could easily get into Obama’s mind.”

As to why  President Obama has to resort to this pattern  of dissimilitude, Cashill referred to a quote from   Leon Panetta ‘s memoir,  Worthy Fights, former CIA Director and Secretary of Defense, saying, “The challenges to his legitimacy made him hesitant and uncertain.”  Cashill believes that may explain why Obama has a tendency “to look for a political angle on everything”.

  Cashill then took us back to Libya in 2011 when President Obama said in a televised speech that there was the threat of a imminent genocidal bloodbath akin to what occurred in Rwanda in the 1990’s, requesting that NATO join the battle in Libya.  Cashill  cites  sources saying,  that there was no evidence of genocide  among the 200 killed  by  the Gaddafi forces  battle for Misrata.  Instead, there was  reported ethnic cleansing and lynching of blacks by rebel forces.   He referred back to the Clinton assertion in 1999 that 100,000 Muslim Kosovars had been killed by Serbia to justify the aerial war against Belgrade.   

Benson tossed me a  question about whether the Obama  National Security Advisers invited foreign Muslim Brotherhood  leaders to the White House.  I replied they had been invited  many times over the period from 2012 to 2014.  One of those encounters later influenced remarks by President Obama  supportive of one Muslim Brotherhood scholar in his UN General Assembly address  in late September 2014.  In June 2013, the former National Security Adviser, Tom Donilon, met with Sheik Muhammad Bin Bayyah of the Islamic  Union of Muslim Scholars a deputy to Anti-Semitic  Muslim Brotherhood preacher, Yusuf al Qaradawi.  Bin Bayyah had authored a Fatwa in 2004 promoting violence to US forces in Iraq.   Bin Bayyah popped up in May 2014, cited  in a Tweet by the State Department Counterterrorism Bureau for his Fatwa against the Boko Haram seizure of 276 girls at a boarding school in Nigeria. To cap things off, there were references to Bin Bayyah  by  President Obama in this year’s address at the  UN General  Assembly. Obama said, “The ideology of ISIL or al Qaeda or Boko Haram will wilt and die if it is consistently exposed, confronted, and refuted in the light of day. Look at the new Forum for Promoting Peace in Muslim Societies—Sheikh bin Bayyah described its purpose; ‘We must declare war on war, so the outcome will be peace upon peace.’ Obama said, quoting the controversial cleric.

How did occur?  We noted  Deputy  National Security Adviser and speechwriter  Ben  Rhodes who  authored  President Obama’s Muslim Outreach speech given in Cairo  in 2009. A classified Presidential Study  Directive 11 (PSD-11)  was commissioned  by the President in 2010  to conduct an assessment of the Muslim Brotherhood and other “political Islamist” movements, including the ruling AKP in Turkey. The PSD  concluded  that the US should shift from its longstanding policy of supporting “stability” in the Middle East and North Africa (that is, support for “stable regimes” even if they were authoritarian), to a policy of backing “moderate” Islamic political movements. PSD-11 remains classified as the Gulf News  reported  in June 2014 because    it “reveals an embarrassingly naïve and uninformed view of trends in the Middle East and North Africa  region.”

When Benson brought up  Obama and his Deputy National Security Adviser McDonough’s  remarks that, “Israel has no better  friend than this Administration  since Harry Truman in 1948,” Cashill said “that’s not what people in Israel say.” 

Dr. Jack Cashill could have gone on  for hours.  Listen to the  podcast  of the October 19, 2014 Lisa Benson Show.

clear
Posted on 10/20/2014 7:10 PM by Jerry Gordon
clear
Monday, 20 October 2014
Adam Yahiye Gadahn Of Al-Qaeda Fame, Has A Little Problem With Economics
clear

In the brand-new first issue of the English-language edition of the Al Qaeda recruitment magazine Resurgence, Adam Yahiye Gadahn lays out targets for Al Qaeda supporters, in groups and groupuscules and lone wolves, to attack. And first on the list are oil tankers and oil pipelines in the Middle East itself.

Now think for a minute. Even if there is not a single attack, the price of insuring those tankers and those pipelines by insurance companies, which are all in the West, will skyrocket. This means that Middle Eastern oil will become, relative to other oil, more expensive than it would otherwise be, and that, in turn, means that the market share of Muslim Arab producers will go down or, in order to stay competitive, they will have to lower the prices of their crude. And that means less money for the Muslim Arabs, which also means less to play with or contribute to the economic jihad (which includes access to Arab markets), and the diplomatic jihad (which requires, often, bribes to diplomats and leaders in countries from Europe to sub-Saharan Africa) and the propaganda jihad (which, again, requires money). The less money the Arabs get from oil and gas revenues, the weaker Muslims become. Keep up the advice column, Mr. Lonelyhearts of the Hadramaut, formerly of California, Mr. Adam Yahiye Gadahn. At long last you're cooking with gas!

clear
Posted on 10/20/2014 2:38 PM by Hugh Fitzgerald
clear
Monday, 20 October 2014
Does Erdogan Not Realize How Furious Everyone Is Becoming With Him?
clear

He dares to be furious, according to reports, with the American government. Tant pis.

clear
Posted on 10/20/2014 2:35 PM by Hugh Fitzgerald
clear
Monday, 20 October 2014
Cold Turkey
clear

College students should be able to answer some simple questions. Which country in the Middle East has been declared guilty of “ethnic cleansing?” Which country in the area has prevented the return of refugees to their homes and former properties? Which country has flouted Article 49 of the 4th Geneva Convention of August 1949 that prohibits an occupying power from deporting or transferring parts of its own civilian population into the territory it occupies? Which country is responsible for a unilateral declaration of independence?  Contrary to what they may hear from their professors, the correct answer is that all these things are performed by Turkey.

Turkey is not the flavor of the month. To say that Turkey is a disappointment in the fight against Islamist terrorism is to state, even understate, a truism. Turkey is a member of NATO, the only Muslim member of the organization, and President Barack Obama still regards it as a regional ally, and as a symbol of Islamic moderation and liberalism.  However, in view of its behavior in recent years, no one can view it as a helpful partner to the US and the other countries prepared to counter Islamic terrorism. In 2003, before the Second Gulf War, the invasion of Iraq against Saddam Hussein, Turkey refused to allow the US to use its bases in the country.  It is still refusing to support the US led coalition to deal with the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria, and again has prevented US reconnaissance and bombing sorties over Syria from the US air base at Incirlik.

To this unhelpful and uncooperative policy has been added even more negative behavior, the direct and indirect help given by Turkey to terrorist groups, Hamas in the Gaza Strip, the Islamic State, and other terrorist groups.  Turkey provided logistical support and sheltered Hamas operatives. It helped the Nusra Front, the al-Qaeda affiliate in Syria. It helped the Islamic State (IS) by allowing arms, material, and personnel to pass through Turkish territory, and through black market transactions with Iran it enables IS to sell the oil from the 10 oil fields and refineries it has seized.  By these sales IS gains about $2 million a day. Erdogan denies this relationship with Iran, which is continuing, thus violating the policy of sanctions against that state.

All this is familiar and distressing. Equally well known and deplorable is the refusal of Turkish President Recep Yayyip Erdogan to allow the considerable Kurdish minority some form of autonomy or self-determination in Turkey.  He views and executes the fight by military attacks and fighter jets against Kurdish groups, especially the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) that he regards as a terrorist group, as more important than the fight against the Islamic State.   Erdogan has even refused to allow US arms transfers to go to the Kurds who are really fighting the main threat to the world, the Islamic State.

What is less familiar or ignored is that Turkey is guilty of crimes as defined by international law because of its occupying of territory and encouraging settlements in a country to which it has no rightful claim. President Erdogan has been all too ready to criticize the State of Israel for occupation, its settlements, and its actions.  Sometimes this criticism is expressed mildly but more often it is in excessive and belligerent language. In May 2010 he accused Israel of “state terrorism” for preventing the flotilla organized from Turkey from sailing into Gaza.  He remarked of Israel’s Operation Protective Edge in Gaza in July 2014 that it was “worse than Nazi genocide…and (Israeli) barbarism has surpassed even Hitler’s.”

Erdogan’s rhetoric suggests he may be a believer in “Jewish world conspiracy or Jewish power,” and even in the blood libel, ritual murder accusations of Jews killing Christians for their blood to make matzos for Passover. Either consciously or unconsciously, this kind of rhetoric echoes antisemitism. He asserted that Israel was behind the ouster of President Mohamed Morsi in Egypt who was removed from power in July 2013 by Field Marshal el-Sisi. Erdogan also called on the world to stop Israel’s desire for genocide because its lust for blood would not end

Erdogan is eager to call on the world for action concerning Israel, but when the “world” speaks about his own misdeeds or those of his country he ignores it. He refuses to acknowledge the opposition of the world to Turkey’s illegal occupation of part of the island of Cyprus. The issue is a simple one. Cyprus, which had been under British administration since 1878 and had been a British Crown Colony since 1925, became an independent country, the Republic of Cyprus, in 1960, according to a Treaty of Guarantee signed by Britain, Greece, and Turkey. However, hostilities between Greek and Turkish Cypriots began in 1963. A UN force, the Peacekeeping Force in Cyprus (UNFICYP), was set up in March 1964 to help restore normal conditions following this violence. Fifty years later UNFICYP is still there, now under the leadership of a woman general from Norway, trying to maintain stability in the area.

On July 20, 1974, 30,000 Turkish troops invaded the island, and they seized and held about a third of it.  In what can be seen as Turkish ethnic cleansing, more than 180,000 Greek Cypriots were evicted from their homes in the north of the island, while 50,000 Turkish Cypriots moved to areas under the control of the Turkish forces.  Contrary to the Geneva and other international Conventions, Turkey has transferred some of its own population into the area.

On November 15, 1983 Turkish Cypriot authorities unilaterally declared the establishment of an independent state, the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus (TRNC). The United Nations Security Council immediately considered this declaration legally invalid and called for its withdrawal. The European Union also condemned this unilateral declaration of independence. Nevertheless, Turkey has ignored this “call on the world for action,” even though no country except Turkey has recognized the legitimacy of the TRNC state.

Those concerned with Middle East issues should not be oblivious, as many have been, to the improper nature and significance of Turkish behavior in Cyprus, the illegal occupation of part of a country, the establishment of Turkish settlements in the area, the continuing presence of Turkish troops, and even the imposition of a Green Line that separates the two political entities in Cyprus. For some years the UN Security Council has been passing resolutions about this situation, the most recent one being Resolution UNSC Res. 2135 of January 30, 2014, commenting on the degree of stability along the Green Line.

But Turkey has not only defied the UN regarding its illegal occupation and settlement policies. It has blatantly denied political reality and threatened hostilities against the legitimate Republic of Cyprus. On October 13, 2014, President Erdogan reprimanded a Greek Cypriot member of the European Parliament who referred to Turkish troops in North Cyprus as “invaders.” He also refused to listen to proposals for withdrawal of Turkish troops.  When the EU admitted Cyprus as a member, Erdogan commented that it should have been admitted as “southern Cyprus….there was no country named Cyprus.” In fact the whole island had been admitted as a member, but EU common rights and obligations refer only to the part under the internationally recognized government, the Republic of Cyprus. In January 2014 Turkey refused to implement fully the customs agreement with the EU because it would include Cyprus.

Erdogan, an authoritarian and belligerent ruler, who has been accused of corruption and of undermining the independence of the judiciary, had already in September 2011 threatened to attack the Republic of Cyprus if it allowed the US based Noble Energy Company to drill for gas in the large Leviathan natural gas field that Israel is exploring. The international community, to which Erdogan so often appeals regarding the actions of Israel, should now condemn Turkey for its displacement of persons, ethnic cleansing, deprivation of the rights of individuals, and racist and ethnic discrimination against minorities that are not Muslim or Sunnis.

First published in the American Thinker.

clear
Posted on 10/20/2014 12:28 PM by Michael Curtis
clear
Monday, 20 October 2014
Betrayal in the Metropolitan Opera Production of the Death of Klinghoffer
clear