Tuesday, 21 March 2006
A left-handed axe to grind...

It's fascinating that, at one point or another, most societies, from Arabs to Romans to Inuits, seem to have been leery of the southpaw in their midst. Arguably, we were the first minority, the first "other" in our communities, as Ben Franklin adroitly pointed out in "A Petition of the Left Hand":

I address myself to all the friends of youth, and conjure them to direct their compassionate regards to my unhappy fate, in order to remove the prejudices of which I am the victim.  There are twin sisters of us; and the two eyes of man do not more resemble, nor are capable of being upon better terms with each other, than my sister and myself, were it not for the partiality of our parents, who make the most injurious distinctions between us.

I'm very thankful to exist in a place and time where left-handedness has been stripped of much of the stigma and superstition that used to accompany it, and still accompanies it in some places. Still, I think I just scraped by at the end of that era, having memories of a kindergarten teacher handing me the right-handed scissors and insisting to me, "You're right-handed!" I thought that to be a simple factual error, and protested, not knowing what the big deal was.

From Fox News: "What Makes a Lefty: Myths and Mysteries Persist"

Lefties have long suffered. In India and Indonesia, as well as in most Islamic countries, eating with the left hand is considered impolite.

Chinese characters prove extremely difficult to write with the left hand. Not so long ago, teachers slapped the wrists of left-handed American elementary students.

Humans have shown the ability to learn to use their non-preferred hand after injuries, when required to perform manual labor, or in the face of cultural pressure.

Yet preference for handedness appears to take root in the womb, or even earlier.

...

Brain damage from trauma in the delivery room is another explanation.

"Proud lefties cringe at the thought of it," said the left-handed Wolman.

"The genetic model has wider support among the laterality community than brain damage at birth or levels of hormones in the womb," Wolman said. "At the end of the day, everyone seems to go back to the gene."

Yeah, let's go with the gene...

Posted on 03/21/2006 9:45 PM by Marisol Seibold
Comments
22 Mar 2006
Mary Jackson
That's very interesting.

In my experience, left-handed people are cleverer than average. I have no idea whether this is true generally.

I'm right handed, except when it comes to steering, eg a bike or a car. If I have to steer with one hand I find it easier to steer with my left hand. No idea why.

Do you have to adapt your instruments at all?

22 Mar 2006
Send an emailEsmerelda Weatherwax
I believe it is definitely genetic.
My Mother was left handed. The raps over the knuckles and other punishments at school failed to make her right handed (they may have worked on my dad who was ambidextrous) but did give her such a complex about her writing that she would not write if she could help it. I remember my first day at school very clearly. She told the headmistress very firmly that I was left handed and I was to be allowed to remain so. The head was so kind about realising what my mother had suffered that she completely understood the notes of absence written in my hand at my mother's dictation and signed by her.

I knit right handed. I sew left handed. I use right handed scissors in my left hand but I must have a left handed potato peeler.
I married a left hander (who learned to fire a rifle right handed) and our daughter is left handed. We eat our dinners right handed, and soup and puddings left handed. We use a right handed mouse, to the left of the keyboard
We confuse everybody.
Which is how we like it.

22 Mar 2006
Send an emailEsmerelda Weatherwax
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/sci/tech/4831218.stm
Snails with left-handed shells can have a big advantage in life - predators may find it impossible to eat them.

22 Mar 2006
Marisol Seibold
Mary-- my being left-handed might have something to do with it, but I totally agree about left-handed steering. Besides, when the steering wheel is on the left side of the vehicle, the right hand controls the radio. ;)

As for instruments, I never thought twice about the right hand/left hand issue until I started studying classical guitar, when suddenly that non-dominant right hand was called upon for tasks involving an unprecedented amount of coordination. That initial learning curve was the only time I thought I might be at a disadvantage, but it's adapted to the challenge over time... aside from keeping a good set of nails on those fingers.

23 Mar 2006
Send an emailEsmerelda Weatherwax
So you don't do a Hendrix then?
Righthanded guitar played left handed and upside down?
Probably wise.