Protesting Ateek and Sabeel is not a violation of free speech; it is a call for intelligent and honest speech.
by Moshe Dann
Because he is an Anglican priest, Ateek’s message to Christians is widely accepted. His organization, Friends of Sabeel, has branches in North America, the United Kingdom, Scandinavia, Norway, Australia, Ireland, the Netherlands, Germany and France. His toxic message of lies and hatred is heard by tens of millions throughout the world.
Dexter van Zile writes (“Rolling out the anti-Zionist Catechism,” JCPA, 2012): “Ateek and Sabeel have become the most effective anti-Zionist evangelists in the American mainline churches today,” including World Council of Churches (WCC), Disciples of Christ, United Church of Christ, Lutheran, Methodist, Presbyterian and Episcopal church organizations, and the Quakers (Society of Friends).
According to Professor Gerald Steinberg, president of NGO Monitor, a Jerusalem-based research organization, “Sabeel, Kairos and DCI-PS (Defense for Children International-Palestinian Section) are three components of a wide NGO network that propels the ‘Durban strategy,’ whose objective is the ‘complete international isolation’ of Israel as an ‘apartheid state.’ ” (“Blood libels and delegitimization,” Jerusalem Report, June 17, 2013)
Dan Diker observes (“BDS Unmasked: radical roots, extremist ends.” JCPA, 2016), “ … many church-linked international NGOs are major donors to radical BDS-supporting NGO’s—for example, Christian Aid in the United Kingdom, Sweden’s Diakonia and the Interchurch Organization for Development Cooperation (ICCO) in the Netherlands.”
Yet Jewish organizations have failed to counter Ateek effectively. Some have published monographs, papers and blogs about Ateek and Sabeel, but these efforts reach few, and those who are already convinced. They remain in the archives of good intentions. Some American and U.K. Jewish leaders do not even know about the problem; others rely on interfaith “good will.”
The question is why Jewish organizations have not responded effectively to growing anti-Semitism and anti-Israelism. As Jonathan Weisman wrote recently in The New York Times, “If not quite a crisis, it feels like a proto-crisis, something to head off … Yet American Jewish leaders … have been remarkably quiet.”
No organization or Jewish leader has challenged the churches and institutions that support Ateek and Sabeel. Writing op-eds and providing information on websites are not enough. Failure to actively and systematically confront Ateek has allowed him to spew his “theology” of hatred and bigotry.
The Israeli government, especially the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and officials dealing with Diaspora affairs, are also culpable. Ateek should be (but is not) considered an enemy of the state and the Jewish people.
Holding conferences on anti-Semitism and well-meaning speeches without sustained and focused leadership accomplish little or nothing. A new office in the Ministry of Strategic Affairs dedicated to combating the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement is narrowly focused on legal efforts, with some success, but misses fundamental issues.
The following quotes are from Ateek’s book.
Ateek condemns Israel as a “settler colonialist” state that seeks “to dispossess the Palestinians—Muslims and Christians—of their land and replace them with Jews,” who engage in “ethnic cleansing and annihilation.” He criticizes Judaism as a form of “tribalism,” a “racist theology” practiced by people who worship “a god who has been created in the image of those who are thirsty for revenge,” based on “exclusive biblical texts that are being used to justify the ethnic cleansing of Palestinians.”
He justifies “Palestinian resistance” as “the right to resist the evil of illegal occupation of our country.” Therefore, “we must work for the liberation of the oppressors, as well as the liberation of the oppressed.” This struggle, he insists, follows the path of liberation taught by Jesus, and, in a sneaky effort to create empathy, he insists that “Jesus was a Palestinian”—a century before the Romans changed the name from Judea after crushing the Bar Kochba rebellion in 135 C.E.
Although he espouses “non-violent resistance,” which he identifies with the First Intifada in the late 1980s, including throwing stones and gasoline bombs (during which about 100 Israelis and 60 soldiers were killed, and more than 1,000 Palestinians were killed by intra-Arab fighting), he completely ignores the massive, virulent terrorism of the Second Intifada from 2000-03 (during which more than 1,200 Israelis were killed, and 10,000 seriously injured), and it continues to exist. Not a word.
Nor, inexplicably, does he mention the decimation and persecution of Christian communities that are under Palestinian Authority/Hamas rule. He ignores the fact that Christians are more protected in Israel than any other country in the region, except perhaps Lebanon.
Ateek also opposes Christians in Israel who seek to join the Israel Defense Forces and support Israel.
“The faith Nakba has made it clear that if the Palestinian Christian community wanted to reinvigorate its religious life, it was essential to reexamine the meaning of its faith and Christian responsibility in light of Israel’s oppression of its people.” This is “the will of God … as expressed in the message and life of Jesus Christ.”
Towards that end, Ateek, Sabeel and the Kairos Palestinian document call for “a system of economic sanctions and boycott to be applied against Israel … to put an end to Israeli occupation of Palestine … ”
“Justice for Palestinians,” he proclaims, but not for Israeli Jews.
And then, lest we forget, because of “Western guilt” and to “speed up the implementation of the Balfour Declaration … the rights and wishes of the Palestinians” were ignored, and the State of Israel was declared (the “Nakba”). “Palestinians were the easy scapegoats … compelled to pay the price [for the Holocaust] by their dispossession and loss of homeland … Palestine and its people were sacrificed on the altar of Western guilt.”
“One cannot exaggerate the psychological influence that the Holocaust exerted in the creation of the state of Israel. If the Nakba necessitated the emergence of Palestinian liberation theology, the Holocaust was an essential part of its background.”
As former Chief Rabbi Jonathan Sacks explained: “Antisemitism is not about Jews. It is about anti-Semites. It is about people who cannot accept responsibility for their own failures and have instead to blame someone else. … The appearance of antisemitism in a culture is the first symptom of a disease, the early warning sign of collective breakdown … Antisemitism means denying the right of Jews to exist as Jews with the same rights as everyone else. The form this takes today is anti-Zionism.” (“The Mutating Virus of Antisemitism”).
British leaders, however, have not asked why the Anglican Church of England supports Ateek and Sabeel. The British media is silent.
Finally, Ateek and his supporters are not only a “Jewish problem;” they are—because they undermine communal trust and respect—a Christian problem. Using his version of Christianity as a mask for his political/theological agenda, he savages the fundamental values and tenets of the religion which he claims to serve.
Protesting Ateek and Sabeel is not a violation of free speech; it is a call for intelligent and honest speech. It is a protest against hatred and propaganda, and a call for integrity and truth. That can be an important learning experience.
From a press release a few years ago: "In The Vatican Against Israel: J’Accuse, author Guilio Meotti accuses the Catholic Church of virulent hostility to the Jewish state, and painstakingly documents how the Church continues to abandon the Jews and the State of Israel in their darkest moments and times of need. “For over 100 years, and half a century after the Holocaust, the Vatican has been hostile to the creation of a Jewish homeland in the Middle East with its capital as Jerusalem,” explains Meotti Catholicism, he says, has long viewed Judaism as a pariah faith, and the Jews a group destined to wander the earth for their complicity in the death of Jesus." It's obviously not only a Catholic phenomenon... In order to consolidate this hatred, Meotti explains, the church leaders in the Middle East have busied themselves forming relationships with the Muslims. Apparently these "relationships" didn't work out too well for some reason, and as a result Christianity in the Middle East has been essentially killed off. Literally.
Mainline Christianity is lost in a wilderness of apostasy. The United Methodist Church is a bellwether of Protestant assimilation by leftist sacrilege. The failure to support Judaism is a fundamental evil proscribed throughout scripture. As institutional Christianity continues along its path leading to destruction, a remnant of the faithful are rising up to condemn apostolic excess and reaffirm Christ as the head of His church.
Ateek is either a full-blown Dhimmi, obediently carrying water for the jihad that is intended to expand Islam (not only by annihilating Israel, but by annihilating all other non-Islamic sovereign states in the whole wide world), or else he is something even nastier, a closet Musilm in 'deep-cover' mode. Does he ever use the term 'Dhimmi", or allude to the wretched and precarious lot of Jews, Christians and Samaritans in the Muslim-occupied Land of Israel (as also everywhere else in the dar al Islam) throughout the entire period of Muslim imperial invasion and occupation? His condemnation of local Israel-resident Arabic-speaking Christians who take Fr Gabriel Naddaf's advice and join the IDF in order to help defend the non-Islamic state within which they are far safer and freer than is any non-Islamic person in any Muslim-dominated state the world over, is very telling. In essence, he is condemning them (as he also condemns sovereign Israel) for breaching the Dhimma pact which says the Dhimmi cannot own or bear arms and must not strike a Muslim (not even in self-defence against outright Muslim aggression and assault). I would encourage the Israelis to see to it that Australian - Anglican - scholar Mark Durie's book "The Third Choice: Islam, Dhimmitude and Freedom", is translated into Hebrew, French, Russian and - *this is especially important* - into the dialect of Arabic used by Christians resident within Israel. I think Fr Gabriel Naddaf would find it very helpful in understanding the mind-warping that afflicts many in his community. (The same book gives a good insight into the psychological ills that often afflict those whose forebears endured the seven hells of Dhimmitude under Muslim overlords - I think of, for example, many in the Balkans, and many in India, and even of many Jews in Israel whose forebears lived as Dhimmis in North Africa, Egypt, Syria, Lebanon, Iraq, Persia...). Durie's companion volume, "Liberty to the Captives', might also be helpful for the likes of Fr Naddaf, if translated into Arabic. Durie's work distils and builds upon, and extends - by additional original research in Islamic texts - the pioneering labours of the Egyptian-Jewish scholar Bat Yeor who investigated the Dhimma system in her books "The Dhimmi" (1983), "The Decline of Eastern Christianity Under Islam", and "Islam and Dhimmitude" (which books, if not already available and circulating in both Hebrew and Levantine Arabic, *ought* to be). My prayer for the Christians within Israel, and also for many Jews within Israel (!!) is that they will be set free from a dhimmi or dhimmified mindset. I also pray that the curse or demonic spirit that manifests in insane Jew-hatred will be removed from those Christians who are currently possessed by it. Question - has anyone ever confronted Naim Ateek with the Arab Muslim slogan 'First the Saturday people, then the Sunday people"? It should surely be possible for persons such as Mordechai Kedar or Raphael Israeli to unearth documented examples of the howling of this slogan by Muslim mobs at times long, long antedating the restoration of the Jewish state of Israel.