Arabs who kill are mentally ill; nothing to do with religion ?

by Theodore Dalymple

I was in France when a friend told me that a woman had been stabbed to death in Russell Square and five other people injured. He challenged me to guess the origins of the perpetrator. A little later, I looked at a report of the incident on the website of the Guardian newspaper. There was no mention in the article of the origin of the perpetrator, a Somalian of Norwegian nationality. Even the next day, the article devoted to the subject mentioned it only sotto voce, as it were, halfway through the article, which until then was mostly about how excellent a woman the victim had been.

Why the reticence, one might ask? Would there have been the same reticence had the perpetrator been, say, a shaven-headed, tattooed lout belonging to an English nationalist party? One rather suspects not.

The police have so far not found any evidence that the perpetrator had a link to any terrorist organisation, though one at least of the latter rejoiced on its website in the murder. I am perfectly prepared to believe that the crime was not terrorism: after all, such horrible incidents occurred before terrorism so preoccupied us, and will continue to occur after terrorism has ceased. The young man was said to have had ‘mental health issues,’ a loose phrase that encompasses everything from losing one’s temper to smoking cannabis – which, incidentally, might well have played an part in the events. Another possible contributor might have been the Somali national drug of abuse, khat, which might have caused a kind of madness.

I was impressed once again by the police’s ability to find just the wrong word to describe a high-profile crime. They did not think that this crime was linked to terrorism; rather, they said, they thought it was just a ‘random’ attack.

It seems to have escaped their notice that one tactic of terrorism is to attack at random, a random attack sowing terror in a population much more effectively than an attack on a target chosen for understandable, even if reprehensible, reasons.

As for the delicacy of the Guardian in the matter of the culprit’s origins, it could hardly be because it imagined that its readers would go out and lynch Somalis wherever they found them. Rather, it was a manifestation of what Freudians call reaction-formation, that is to say a response to its own deep-seated, and therefore much feared, racism, another manifestation of which is its obsession with race and racial politics.


3 Responses

  1. Of course, this Muslim – of Somali ethnicity – was *not* Arab.

    Other curious episodes of 'mental illness' of late have been perpetrated not only by Muslims of Arab ethnicity but by Muslims of *other* quite different ethnic backgrounds. 

    When *I* heard about this stabbing in London it didn't even occur to me to speculate as to what 'race' the attacker might have been; but I had a very strong feeling that he might well be a Muslim; and if Muslim, he could quite easily have been an ethnically-British convert, rather than – as in this case he did turn out to be – an ethnically-Somali 'cradle Muslim'.

    One of the reasons why I was not at all surprised to discover the perp was a Muslim, was that the modus operandi was so very, very similar to that of a great many stabbing murders – and attempted murders – that have been carried out by Muslims (male and female, both adult and juvenile) inside Israel over the past nine months and more. (Just as the attack in Nice was strongly reminiscent of the use of vehicles, by Muslims, to attack and kill Jewish pedestrians, in various attacks that have taken place in recent years).  In the case of the stabbings in Israel, of course, the stabbers *are* all ethnically Arab… but *none* of them have been Druze, or Arab Christians, or Arab atheists or communists; one and all, they have been Muslims.

  2. What about expanding the DSM-V to include Islamopathology, treating the doctrine as a disease?  That's plainly what it is.

  3. This blog's last sentence refering to the Guardian's reluctance to mention the killer's ethnicity as 'reaction formation' seems spot on. In fact much of the recent politically correct rage against racism sems to have the same origin in attempts to deny deepseated racial hatreds.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

New English Review Press is a priceless cultural institution.
                              — Bruce Bawer

Order here or wherever books are sold.

The perfect gift for the history lover in your life. Order on Amazon US, Amazon UK or wherever books are sold.

Order on Amazon, Amazon UK, or wherever books are sold.

Order on Amazon, Amazon UK or wherever books are sold.

Order on Amazon or Amazon UK or wherever books are sold

Order at Amazon, Amazon UK, or wherever books are sold. 

Order at Amazon US, Amazon UK or wherever books are sold.

Available at Amazon US, Amazon UK or wherever books are sold.

Send this to a friend