Did We Have an Insurrection at the Arizona State Capitol? Just Askin’

by Gary Fouse

On Friday evening, while the Arizona legislature was still in session voting on bills in the Arizona State Capitol building in Phoenix, several thousand protesters, enraged over the US Supreme Court decision on abortion, descended on the building, threatened to break through the glass doors, vandalized outside monuments, and had to be dispersed by police using tear gas. All the while, lawmakers, many of whom later reported having felt like hostages, were evacuated by police.

The comparisons between this event and the January 6, 2021 event in Washington are obvious though the Arizona incident pales in comparison to the Washington incident. But the question is being asked by many: Was what occurred in Phoenix Friday night an insurrection-as many label January 6, an insurrection designed to stop or influence lawmakers inside who were deliberating on other issues?

Just to be clear, I condemn both incidents. Whether January 6 represented an actual attempted insurrection is a matter for debate, but here is my point: Will the reactions to Friday night be similar to the January 6 reactions? In other words, will there be a US Department of Justice investigation, and will charges be brought against the protesters in Arizona-those that can be identified after an exhaustive investigation? Will those charged be held for a year or so in solidarity confinement? Will there be prison sentences? Will there be Congressional hearings? Will our news media, led by CNN, spend the next year or so condemning what happened in Arizona?

Just askin’.

Of course, to be fair, there are contrasts, especially in terms of severity. Nobody was killed Friday night, no police officers were assaulted or injured, and apparently, nobody actually breached the Capitol building. There was no vote ongoing to validate the Supreme Court decision on Roe vs. Wade.

But things did get out of hand in Phoenix, and police had to defend the Capitol from being breached by a mob of thousands of angry protesters while lawmakers were inside conducting the People’s business. It went beyond a peaceful protest.

Of course, hypocrisy cuts both ways, and those who would condemn Friday’s incident in Phoenix but excuse January 6 can fairly be accused of hypocrisy-whatever you think of the 2020 election and whatever you think of the Supreme Court’s decision on abortion. I did not like the results of the 2020 election, and I still have my doubts about what occurred on Election Night in places like Philadelphia, Atlanta, and Milwaukee. I am opposed to abortion, but I think I can understand the anger of those on the other side of the debate.

All of which is irrelevant as far as I am concerned because I condemn both incidents and I concede there are distinctions in terms of severity. But if what happened in Arizona Friday night has disappeared from the news in a couple of days-or not reported at all by certain news sources, then somebody is guilty of hypocrisy.


6 Responses

  1. No.

    If you want to claim that Trump incited an insurrection with his speech on January 6 (“peacefully and patriotically marching to the Capitol”), do you think he was criminally culpable? You can say that it was not the time or place to give his standard take no prisoners stump speech, or that he waited too long before publically appearing and urging the people to go home. But there is a difference between saying he had a moral duty to act otherwise and saying he is criminally responsible for inciting an insurrection. Legally, that’s a high bar, and if it came to that, his phrase “peacefully and patriotically” is exculpatory.

    I do not condemn those who went to hear Trump speak nor those who marched to the Capitol to protest outside. Those who went in and broke things and assaulted cops I do not defend.

  2. Oh please, don’t insult our intelligence. Someone would have to have the innocence of a newborn not to recognize that Donald Trump was, in simple English, covering his ass. The couple of mentions he made of behaving peacefully are vastly overwhelmed by all the things he said that were intended to inflame and incite (“the election was stolen from us”, “we won’t let them steal the election”, etc. etc.). The storming of the Capitol is exactly what The Demagogue wanted to happen.

  3. “I still have my doubts about what occurred on Election Night in places like Philadelphia, Atlanta, and Milwaukee”

    The 2020 election was perfectly legitimate. Claims to the contrary are Trumpian propaganda and have been debunked by numerous reputable organizations.

      1. “Everybody’s got their weaknesses man, so don’t talk to me about mine.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

New English Review Press is a priceless cultural institution.
                              — Bruce Bawer

The perfect gift for the history lover in your life. Order on Amazon US, Amazon UK or wherever books are sold.

Order on Amazon, Amazon UK, or wherever books are sold.

Order on Amazon, Amazon UK or wherever books are sold.

Order on Amazon or Amazon UK or wherever books are sold

Order at Amazon, Amazon UK, or wherever books are sold. 

Order at Amazon US, Amazon UK or wherever books are sold.

Available at Amazon US, Amazon UK or wherever books are sold.

Send this to a friend