By Gerald A. Honigman
The Gatestone Institute recently published a good synopsis of the numerous problems associated with President Trump’s Gaza peace plan which will probably be as effective as his latest “deal” involving talking to Iran’s mullahs while thousands more Iranians are slaughtered in the streets…over a month after he encouraged them to revolt.
As I have painfully and repeatedly written over the past months, the aim of the President and his family’s business partners’s Gaza “deal,” in close collaboration with their oppressive, autocratic Turk and black African slaver Qatari and Saudi Arabian buddies, is not defeat of the butchers in Hamas, who’ve brought misery to their own people as well as unprovoked slaughter of Jews, but, inadvertently, just a Neville Chamberlain-like sellout of Israel as was done to Czechoslovakia in Munich in 1938 to gain a phony “peace for our time,” which resulted in that nation being overrun by the Nazis, and most of the rest of Europe falling to them as well.
Hitler first stated he “just” wanted Czechoslovakia’s mineral-rich Sudetenland, using German settlers in that region to bolster his claims, and wound up conquering almost everyone else soon afterwards.
Israel, the sole, minuscule resurrected nation of too much of the world’s Church indoctrinated “perfidious, god-killing Jews,” (or kilab yahud, “Jew dog,” sons of apes and pigs and killers of prophets in the Arab/Muslim world) is far more expendable today than Christian Czechoslovakia was.
Sadly (I voted for him twice as a NPA Independent), Trump’s team—including his
Jewish son-in-law—traded Israeli lives and the minuscule nation’s minimal existential interests for their own future personal economic gain in the new Gaza mega resort they’re planning to build. To his credit, however, he did achieve some wonderful things during his first term in office—recognizing Jerusalem as the 3,000 year old eternal capital of Israel, since King David bought its site from Jebusite Canaanites. And the Abraham Accords etc defunding UNRWA. recognizing Israeli sovereignty in the Golan Heights, cutting off Iranian oil revenues, etc.
Still, when America was attacked by Imperial Japan and Europe was overrun by Nazi Germany, after that war finally ended, America and the Allies didn’t offer Japan or Germany a “ceasefire” interlude, compromise, or “deal.”
We uncategorically dictated terms of total surrender to our enemies, and dismantled both of their megalomaniacal regimes, hung war criminals, and so forth.
This doesn’t mean all Nazis were killed—just that effective steps were taken to keep them from regaining power, and seeing that new democratic, tolerant institutions and leaders were being created.
The same must happen in Gaza—and in Judea and Samaria as well.
Arabs who support butchering Jews, whether in Hamas or any another organization, will never all be eliminated, but as with the Nazis, with proper counterforce and determination, they can be mostly rendered to nuisance status and eliminated exponentially if creating more carnage.
And whatever Trump’s plan calls for, the actual plan that Israel must insist upon must include a permanent minimum 8-10 mile heavily fortified buffer zone created on the Gaza side of the border…absolutely NO total Israeli withdrawal, ever, regardless of who’s tightening the screws on Israel’s leadership.
Think about what other nations have gained as a result of wars being forced upon them in terms of territory
Gaza, like the Golan Heights, was part of the original 1920 Mandate of Palestine before the French and Brits did some imperial trading, and it has a rich Jewish history going back millennia.
Mahmoud Abbas’s “Pay to Slay” Fatah is merely the flip side of the Arab rejectionist, supremacist terror coin regarding not only Jews, but scores of millions of other non-Arab peoples in the region seeking their own fair share of justice. Kurds, Druze, Assyrians, black Africans, Amazigh “Berbers,” Egyptian Copts, and others have been slaughtered by Arab jihadis.
“West Bank” is an imperialist term invented after the original 1920 Mandate of Palestine was chopped apart in 1922, with imperial Great Britain handing over almost 80% of the original territory to its Hashemite Arab allies, who were in the process of getting their derrières booted out of the Arabian Peninsula by Ibn Saud.
Thus the Arab nation (Emirate) of Transjordan was born…
In 1948, British officers led by Sir John Bagot Glubb (“Glubb Pasha”), formed the Arab Legion and, along with about a half dozen other Arab nations, led the attack against a tiny, vulnerable, reborn Israel in 1948.
In the process they crossed the Jordan River and seized 4,000 year old ancestral Jewish lands where Hebrew Prophets preached; Abraham purchased a burial site for the Jews’s Patriarchs and most of their Matriarchs; David, born in Bethlehem of Judah (Judaea) was anointed King of Israel in Hebron by the Prophet Samuel; David’s son King Solomon built the first Temple (which most Arabs claim never existed) in Jerusalem; the Hasmoni family of the “Maccabees (hammers!)” rose in revolt against Greeks and Syrians attempting to paganize them in Mod’in; Jacob wrestled with an Angel of the Lord in a dream to become his better moral self, and became renamed Israel as a result in Penuel; Judaean warriors held out against the mighty imperial Roman army atop Masada, overlooking the Dead Sea in the Judaean Wilderness; etc. and so forth.
For administrative purposes, these lands needed to be distinguished from Transjordan on the East Bank, so they were dubbed the “West Bank”—a term concocted by a collusion of ARABISM (Arab nationalism) and imperial British interests. Holding both banks, Transjordan renamed itself “Jordan” instead.
By the way, Christian friends, does the New Testament say that Yehoshua/Jesus was born in Bethlehem of the West Bank or Bethlehem of Judaea ?
Moving on…
As a consequence of Trump’s forcing Israel to repeatedly act against its own existential interests (resulting in unnecessary deaths and injuries), it seems that Jews are the only people who, after being brutally attacked, are expected to not be allowed by others to win wars with those who openly profess their intent to obliterate their nation and repeat the butchery of October 7th, 2023 over and over again—and which had already been committed against them long before as well…
The President deliberately stopped Israel in its tracks at Saudi Arabia, Qatar, and Sultan Erdogan the Great’s Turkey’s urging, making the IDF forfeit its hard won momentum gained after two years of the hardest fighting that probably exists—urban warfare, where the cowardly enemy embeds itself within the civilian population to deliberately use them as human shields after committing atrocities against Israel, a double war crime according to the Geneva Conventions on War, the Perfidy Clause in particular.
Regaining that momentum will undoubtedly cost more IDF lives, as well as those of Arab civilians…
Typically, there will be those who try to turn all of this into a moral equivalency issue. Wrong…
Arab civilians who die have nobody but the very Jew-hating butchers whom they freely elected to power two decades ago to blame. By the way, antisemite President “Apartheid Israel” Jimmy Carter oversaw that election. Google some of his Sunday school lectures and sermons if you doubt me.
Regarding the nature of the enemy Israel faces, be sure to see some of the graphic photos inside this following link, for they were posted on the internet by numerous “ordinary” Gaza Arabs who gleefully joined Hamas in the wanton slaughter and bloodlust committed on the Hebrew Bible’s Holy Day of Simchat Torah, October 7th, 2023:
Regarding stage two of Trump’s mediocre-to-poor plan, the President knew all along that Hamas would never give up its arms or make any real concessions for peace with Israel.
The answer thus was a no-brainer.
Israel should have been allowed to totally defeat and eradicate as much of Hamas and Islamic Jihad as possible to achieve the same total victory we ourselves demanded over Imperial Japan and Nazi Germany at the end of. World War II.
The Gaza peace keeping force should not include members openly hostile to the actual victim of this tragic war—Israel. But Trump wants military from Turkey, Qatar, and so forth included anyway. Why?
If the President would stop trying to prove he’s the best and most competent at everything for once, such a peacekeeping force actually has been in place for decades in the Sinai Peninsula. It replaced the United Nauseating Nations’s own joke, which withdrew as soon as President Nasser of Egypt ordered it to, helping to cause the June 1967 Six Day War, started by an illegal Egyptian naval blockade, a casus belli.
Read about this effective force in the following link, and ponder why President Trump feels he needs to ignore this ready made organization and, instead, turn the process into a long, dragged out concoction with his own imprimatur on it, which will undoubtedly be far less effective with members quibbling with each other over one thing or another.
There’s so much more that could be addressed here, but I would only suggest that you return to the informative Gatestone Institute analysis found at the beginning of this article.
Except for those planning to make billions of dollars in real estate and building investments in the new proposed Gaza beach paradise, the news has gone from bad to worse since Israel was forced to allow Hamas to rebuild, regroup, rearm, intimidate and murder competition, gather more international support, and so forth by accepting Witkoff’s “hudna” ceasefire, the latter being of the same ilk Arabs have used since Muhammad’s ploy to regain strength in order to eventually defeat his enemies.
5 Responses
The author of this vile grotesquery writes:
“As I have painfully and repeatedly written over the past months, the aim of the President and his family’s business partners’s Gaza “deal,” in close collaboration with their oppressive, autocratic Turk and black African slaver Qatari and Saudi Arabian buddies, is not defeat of the butchers in Hamas, who’ve brought misery to their own people as well as unprovoked slaughter of Jews, but, inadvertently, just a Neville Chamberlain-like sellout of Israel as was done to Czechoslovakia in Munich in 1938 to gain a phony “peace for our time,” which resulted in that nation being overrun by the Nazis, and most of the rest of Europe falling to them as well.”
The author writes that this was painful for him to write. I bet it was.
But there is no way it could have been as painful for me to read.
How does the author know that any or all of the things that he asserts to be true? How does he know that all of this revolting negative hateful speculation is factual, as he presents it? He can’t.
How does the author know that Trump is to be a Chamberlain and a failure? How does the author know that Trump will abandon Israel and allow Hamas to continue to exist and not disarm? How does the author know that Trump will “sellout” Israel? All of Trump’s previous support for Netanyahu, his defense of Israel from Iranian attack, his support of Israel’s right to self-defense all suggest, his freely giving/selling weapons to Israel, all apparently, to this author, all evidence that Trump will “sell out” Israel?
The author can know none of these things.
This is nothing more than a disgusting, negative, hyperventilating, excessive, over-written, self-indulgent, hate-filled, bag of cynical crap – a disgusting, nasty mess unworthy of these pages.
Firstly, as a disciplined scholar and student of this region and national security policy studies, I carefully triple check everything I write.
I didn’t say that Trump’s plan will be the same as Munich 1938, and if you bothered to look at this analysis’s very title, you’d have noticed that I deliberately placed a question mark at its end. Do you understand what the significance of a question mark means?
You’re totally incorrect by implying that Trump gave Netanyahu total support, whether regarding Hamas or Iran..
If you’re going to critique, then get your own facts straight.
America under Trump and Vance repeatedly forced Israel not to go after Iran,, even after Israel was blasted by numerous drones, rockets, powerful ballistic missiles, incendiary devices, and so forth by the mullahs’s proxies’s and Iran itself.
With the nuclear breakout threshold fast arriving for Iran, the Trump team still warned Israel not to retaliate and let Trump’s “dealing” have more time—allowing the mullahs to practice taqiyyah and kitman obfuscation and lying at the negotiating table while continuing to build up its nuclear capabilities and ballistic missile arsenal.
Israel finally could not wait any longer and was forced for existential reasons to go against its best friend’s wishes.
Israel launched a punishing air attack which obliterated much of Iran’s air defense capabilities, both in Iran itself and Syria.
It took out numerous IRGC officers and soldiers and Basij fighters too, along with additional nuclear scientists.
With reports that North Korea was supplying Iran with ICBMs capable of reaching the “Big Satan”—America—as well as the “Little Satan”—Israel—Trump only then realized that the time had come to actually do something instead of warning Israel not to act.
With Iran’s sky now made safe because Israeli pilots took the risk to do the massive job of attacking Iran’s sophisticated Russian and Chinese anti-aircraft missile and radar systems,, Trump then launched the assault on Iran’s deep nuclear sites.
I could go on and on, but you’re not worth my time.
Everything else you challenged me on can be debunked the same way the above has done with your assertions that Trump simply allows Israel to do whatever…
By the way, when our own existential interests are on the line—and America is 3,000 miles wide with two vast oceans acting as fairly effective buffers, as opposed to an Israel 9-15 miles wide at its waist—so we ask anyone before acting in our own interests?
Trump was supposed to be better than the horrendous Obama-Biden-Blinken-Harris crew, and during the first term he was.
If you really read what I wrote, he gets credit for this in my analysis and important links.
But the second term indeed has been very different, as numerous astute observers besides myself have repeatedly pointed out.
Another TDS sufferer!
Sad.
You are engaging in argument by assertion, then when questioned, assert that you triple-checked your work rather than substantiating anything. The point is that your assertions are left unsupported and therefore questionable at best.
Very good…however, I blame Israel for NOT annexing and truly liberating their lands West of the Jordan in July of ’67.
Had Israel annexed Judea, Samaria and Gaza while extirpating Islam – and Communism – from within its borders, world history would be very different today.
I agree with everything above, however one also must consider the opinions being placed into President Trump’s ears by the real estate developers, speculators and moguls: Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff. Perhaps, they also had a hand in Israel’s situation and Trump’s pending “Chamberlainesque” moment.
Very good piece however I always come back to Israel’s failure placing itself into the situation it finds itself today that would be extremely different had Israel recognized what Islam is and their own history actually is as directly associated to the lands of Israel.
I pray Israel do the above and become “a light among the nations” so the rest of us here in the collapsing and invading West might finally do the same…
Good post. Keep up the good work….