The Tale of Two Donalds

by Michael Curtis

Neither film goers nor political commentators might see much in common between Walt Disney’s colorful and noisy character Donald Duck who has delighted audiences for 70 years and the colorful and noisy personality, Donald Trump, who is starring in the political arena  at the present time. Yet, both characters have been involved with Russian affairs in a somewhat unexpected and bizarre fashion. Both of these characters have been unjustly accused of high crimes or misdemeanors, though Trump’s problem was self-inflicted.

Donald Duck has been redeemed. He was on July 28, 2016 found not guilty of a serious crime, and everyone can now recognize he is not a villain. He had been accused of extremism in the city court of Petropavlovsk  Kamchatsky, capital of the Kamchatka region of eastern Siberia. His problem arose as a character in the Walt Disney film, the 8 minute film, “Der Fuehrer’s Face” made in 1942. The director of it won an Oscar for best animated short cartoon in 1943.

The film was part of the US propaganda campaign during World War II. No one could mistake it for anything but a wartime satire, portraying leading Nazis in mocking caricature, not as a serious political commentary on the Nazi system. .

The film portrayed Donald in a nightmare setting, forced to work in an assembly line in a munitions factory making artillery shells in Nazi Germany. He had arrived at the factory at bayonet point. Donald sees a band made up of Joseph Goebbels playing the trombone. Heinrich Himmler playing the drums, Hermann Goering playing the piccolo, and Benito Mussolini on another set of drums. When he wakes up from the nightmare Donald shows he is proud to be a U.S. citizen, and embraces the Statue of Liberty.

A resident of the Siberian town who uploaded the Disney film was accused of inciting racial hatred and enmity and received a six month suspended sentence. The film was put of the federal list of “extremist materials,” thereby making it illegal to produce or distribute in Russia. The list outlaws all items critical of the Russian government, and also Nazi propaganda.

A higher Russian court ruled in July 2016 that the lower court was wrong and that the film could not be regarded as extremist. Donald Duck will therefore be removed from the national list of extremist materials in Russia, a list that has existed in Russia since 2002 and which contains more than 3,700 items.

Satire finally seems to have been understood by some Russians. Now it is time for it to be appreciated by American political and media personalities during this heated presidential campaign. The issue concerns the Republican candidate for the Presidency, whose unequivocal political pronouncements have stirred controversy. At the press conference at his golf resort in Florida on July 27, 2016, Donald Trump uttered one of his many impromptu, sometimes bewildering remarks. He referred indirectly to FBI Director James B. Comey who had commented in a balanced way that it was indeed possible that Hillary Clinton’s server had been accessed, though there was no evidence that it had happened.

The issue related to the leaking and publication by Wikileaks of some 20,000 emails written by members of the Democratic National Committee. Among them were derogatory remarks about Bernie Sanders, Hillary’s political rival, who had been saying for months that the activities of the DNC were rigged against him. More relevant are two other issues. One is the question of why the leaks took place and whether foreign outsiders were aware of the contents of the emails. The other is the unresolved mystery regarding the many emails of Hillary Clinton.

Trump in an off hand, extravagant and thoughtless remark proposed a solution of that mystery. He said, “Russia if you are listening, I hope you’re able to find the 30,000 emails that are missing. I think you’ll be rewarded mightily by our press.”

Understandably, the mainstream U.S. media was annoyed at Trump’s jibe about their seeming lack of interest in pursuing the case of the missing emails. Trump has little flair or timing for comedy, and his remark can be accused of poor judgment. But instead of treating Trump’s provocative statement as an ill judged, poor attempt at satire, the press, as well of course as political opponents, have treated it as if it were a serious policy proposal.

One accepts that US presidential campaigns are heated and one expects that rhetoric used by candidates may sometimes be excessive and even border on the fictional. It is improbable that political opponents have really believed that Trump was calling for a foreign power to carry out cyber-spying on Hillary Clinton or the DNC, or actively encouraging another country to commit a crime against the U.S. Yet, not surprisingly, Jake Sullivan, the senior policy advisor of Hillary, said this was the first time that a major presidential candidate has actively encouraged a foreign power to conduct espionage against his political opponent. One may dislike Trump’s persona and personal style and disagree with the direction of his policy pronouncements but this is different from portraying him as a security risk or guilty of treason.

Yes, words matter and so does the commentary and parsing on them used by political figures. We learned from FBI Director Comey that “extreme carelessness” is not equivalent to “negligence.” International public opinion was surprised when the White House “red line” pertinent in 2012 to the use of chemical weapons by the Assad regime in Syria turned out not to exist.

Donald Trump is not the first prominent person to make a gaffe in trying political humor. In 1984 Ronald Reagan in an off air radio sound check said, “I’ve signed legislation that will outlaw Russia forever. We begin bombing in 5 minutes.” It was unlikely that Russian leaders at the time took Reagan’s joke seriously. It is equally unlikely that President Vladimir Putin has taken Donald Trump’s remark seriously, or that he will respond toTrump as the Russian court once treated Donald Duck. He might even laugh at the joke.


One Response

  1. I do absolutely love the NEW ENGLISH REVIEW….I having been enjoying it for years….

    Honestly, I find Republican Presidential Nominee:  Donald J. Trump to be the Most Refreshing and Exciting thing that has happened to politics in the United States of America since Ronald Reagan.

    The fact that Trump is an "outsider" is WONDERFUL!  It is about time that the United States of America has someone with the "intestinal fortitude" to speak his or her mind!  Sure—Trump says things at times that don't "wear well" with every single person…..but in reality….that is really just everyday living for the average American citizen—or for that matter—for the average citizen wherever they may live…..some countries will not allow a person to speak their mind verbally—but that Does Not Keep Them from thinking!.

    In Donald J. Trump, America Finally has someone who cares enough to "step up to the plate" and take the bad with the good….and fight for America!!!  Anyone with an  IQ "two points above plant life" can see that America is the Image of the Titanic and the only thing still sticking UP ABOVE THE WATER IS!!!  (yOU KNOW WHAT i MEAN!!!)  

    I was thinking about the media attempting to take Trump to task about him asking that the crying baby be removed from the Trump Rally…..He's a Father—and he would have had better sense himself than to take one of his children when they were babies into a crowd of people, shouting and cheering…..Not to Mention: that tiny baby was being exposed to only GOD knows What in that type of close contact.  I am sure Trump deep down was thinking about that child….It is apparent that he is a GREAT Father……GIVE US MORE GREAT MOTHERS AND FATHERS WITH SOME WISDOM WHERE THEIR CHILDREN ARE CONCERNED.

    I would Never have taken my daughter into a crowd like that when she was a baby…I would have had better sense!  AND—if I had….when my Mother found out—SHE WOULD HAVE KILLED ME!!!!

    So, the RACE IS ON!  The Democats are pulling out all of the "STOPS" in their feeding frenzy to try to destroy Trump……The ironic thing about it all is—-

         The more they "trash" Trump (with help from their media buddies) the more the American People turn to Trump!   

    Americans are just plain FEED UP!  Americans are "Long-suffering" people…..but even taking that into consideration……the American People are not nearly as stupid as some in Authority might think…..

    This is a year like no other year in the history of the nation of America…..There are some BIG SURPRISES COMING for the crowd who are "advocating" the same ole' same ole' business as usual….

    ALL of the groundwork being laid to destroy Trump and send him into the "boneyard of history" is NOT going to Work!   Donald J. Trump has been "chosen" for this time and this season to CHANGE COURSE —-and HE knows what to do and how to do it….

    As the world watches and waits for the November election to Declare "The Handwriting on the Wall" — We will All see Who has the Final say……Just because We can't see HIM doesn't mean that HE can't see us…..

    HOLD ON!!!!  The roller coaster ride is just beginning……


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

New English Review Press is a priceless cultural institution.
                              — Bruce Bawer

The perfect gift for the history lover in your life. Order on Amazon US, Amazon UK or wherever books are sold.

Order on Amazon, Amazon UK, or wherever books are sold.

Order on Amazon, Amazon UK or wherever books are sold.

Order on Amazon or Amazon UK or wherever books are sold

Order at Amazon, Amazon UK, or wherever books are sold. 

Order at Amazon US, Amazon UK or wherever books are sold.

Available at Amazon US, Amazon UK or wherever books are sold.

Send this to a friend